Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • vnzla81
    Member
    • Jul 2008
    • 68174

    Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

    Originally posted by Ace E.Anderson
    So I present this question to the forum...

    COMPLETELY HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION MIND YOU. SO PLEASE DO NOT THINK THAT THIS IS A PREDICTION OF SOME SORT

    Griffin is already considered by many to be the most electrifying player going in the NFL thus far this season. If he were able to garner 1st place votes for the MVP award, or even somehow managed to win the award (though unlikely--a few journalists have begun stating that he's in the discussion) would you then be willing to consider that he's a better player than Luck?
    I think he is a pro-baller this year, I know that doesn't mean much but still....
    @WhatTheFFacts: Studies show that sarcasm enhances the ability of the human mind to solve complex problems!

    Comment

    • Gamble1
      Member
      • Apr 2007
      • 7257

      Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

      To your question ace. If RG3 wins the nfl mvp I defiantly would put him ahead of luck for the season. I doubt that happens but who knows.

      Comment

      • Ace E.Anderson
        Member
        • Dec 2011
        • 18261

        Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

        Originally posted by vnzla81
        I think he is a pro-baller this year, I know that doesn't mean much but still....
        Easily. I'm thinking he'll easily be the leading vote getter, lol if they even do that anymore. If not I'd think he, Manning and Rodgers would be the NFC pro bowlers.

        Comment

        • Ace E.Anderson
          Member
          • Dec 2011
          • 18261

          Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

          Originally posted by Gamble1
          To your question ace. If RG3 wins the nfl mvp I defiantly would put him ahead of luck for the season. I doubt that happens but who knows.
          I doubt it does too. I hadn't even thought bout that till I read something about it online and then heard it again on ESPN. At some point he has to hit that rookie wall, and have a bad game or two

          Comment

          • Bball
            Jimmy did what Jimmy did
            • Jan 2004
            • 26903

            Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

            Originally posted by Ace E.Anderson
            So I present this question to the forum...

            COMPLETELY HYPOTHETICAL QUESTION MIND YOU. SO PLEASE DO NOT THINK THAT THIS IS A PREDICTION OF SOME SORT

            Griffin is already considered by many to be the most electrifying player going in the NFL thus far this season. If he were able to garner 1st place votes for the MVP award, or even somehow managed to win the award (though unlikely--a few journalists have begun stating that he's in the discussion) would you then be willing to consider that he's a better player than Luck?
            If he was to win the MVP then it would mean his rookie season has surpassed Luck. It SHOULD also mean RG3's team has improved considerably because I think the MVP should be reserved for a player that markedly makes his team much, much better than they already would be. While that doesn't preclude it going to a team with a mediocre or worse record, it should certainly come close to doing that.
            Nuntius was right for a while. I was wrong for a while. But ultimately I was right and Frank Vogel has been let go.

            ------

            "A player who makes a team great is more valuable than a great player. Losing yourself in the group, for the good of the group, that’s teamwork."

            -John Wooden

            Comment

            • OlBlu
              Banned
              • Dec 2011
              • 3288

              Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

              Originally posted by Bball
              If he was to win the MVP then it would mean his rookie season has surpassed Luck. It SHOULD also mean RG3's team has improved considerably because I think the MVP should be reserved for a player that markedly makes his team much, much better than they already would be. While that doesn't preclude it going to a team with a mediocre or worse record, it should certainly come close to doing that.
              It won't happen. That team is probably a .500 team at best. MVP goes to a winning team. He might get offensive player of the year to go with the rookie of the year he will surely win.

              Comment

              • cdash
                Whale Shepherd
                • Jun 2009
                • 32259

                Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                If Andrew Luck wins MVP, OlBlu would still find a way to minimize his accomplishments. Don't misconstrue this situation: The unreasonable and totally irrational side of this is anything OlBlu is arguing. The RGIII backlash on here is almost solely Blu's production. Bravo, troll.

                Comment

                • Swingman
                  Member
                  • Sep 2005
                  • 848

                  Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                  Ace,

                  Griffin winning MVP is about as likely as pigs flying but sure, in that case I'd say he had a better SEASON than Luck. Obviously he'd have to in order to get the award. I wouldn't go so far as to say his career is guaranteed to be better than Luck's career.

                  On flip side, do you think Olblu would give Luck any credit if Luck were to win MVP? More likely Olblu would be shouting conspiracy theories and stats to try to show why Luck is undeserving.

                  Comment

                  • OlBlu
                    Banned
                    • Dec 2011
                    • 3288

                    Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                    Originally posted by Swingman
                    Ace,

                    Griffin winning MVP is about as likely as pigs flying but sure, in that case I'd say he had a better SEASON than Luck. Obviously he'd have to in order to get the award. I wouldn't go so far as to say his career is guaranteed to be better than Luck's career.

                    On flip side, do you think Olblu would give Luck any credit if Luck were to win MVP? More likely Olblu would be shouting conspiracy theories and stats to try to show why Luck is undeserving.
                    Mark me down as someone who does not think that Luck will ever win an MVP but would not be surprised at all if Peyton Manning won another one (probably not this sure but it could happen)....

                    Comment

                    • xBulletproof
                      I have a Member
                      • Jun 2010
                      • 4671

                      Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                      RG3 is playing better currently, no idea how anyone can debate that.

                      That said, he's got more support. That's going to help. Common sense dictates that if Luck wasn't throwing 40+ times per game his efficiency would go up because teams weren't playing so geared up for stopping the pass. Yet, we don't have a choice, he's the best chance we have at getting the ball down the field. If he was passing 27 times per game like RG3, I would bet he'd be quite a bit more efficient. However that's not how things are playing out, so RG3 is playing better. He's passing better and running better no matter the reason.

                      In the long run though, the Redskins need to tone down his carries. He's on pace for 150 carries. Michael Vick's career high? 123. Randall Cunningham? He broke 100 carries only twice in his career. Steve Young? RG3 will probably pass Steve Young's career high for rushes in a season in the next week or two. He's already had a concussion just a few games into his career and as we know, those things get easier to get as you keep having them. That's at least 2 for RG3 that I know of. RG3 just isn't big enough to sustain that kind of beating in the way Michael Vick hasn't been.

                      Even though RG3 is playing better at the moment, I just don't see it sustaining itself over the course of a career. Running QB's in the NFL have a very sketchy track record in NFL history, and pocket passers are well proven. While RG3 looks like a superstar in the making, so did Cam Newton last year. The real test is when the NFL has time to learn tendencies and make the young guys adjust to them and what they're doing to take away what they're good at. Ask Cam Newton.

                      Comment

                      • Trader Joe
                        DIET COKE!
                        • Jan 2006
                        • 46892

                        Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                        RGIII is having a great season so far no doubt, but anyone who thinks a member of a losing team is going to win the MVP is smoking some serious stuff that I want to get my hands on.


                        Comment

                        • Gamble1
                          Member
                          • Apr 2007
                          • 7257

                          Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                          Originally posted by Ace E.Anderson
                          I doubt it does too. I hadn't even thought bout that till I read something about it online and then heard it again on ESPN. At some point he has to hit that rookie wall, and have a bad game or two
                          RG3 season depends on the games coming up against tough competition. If he does well against the steelers and baltimore then I think he has a good shot at being rookie of the year. I wouldn't consider it a lock though for him to make the pro bowl considering the qbs with better
                          Records overall.

                          Comment

                          • vnzla81
                            Member
                            • Jul 2008
                            • 68174

                            Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                            Newton is not comparable to RG3, RG3 is mentally stable just the same way Luck is, Newton to me has the same mentality as TO, great talent but has nothing in his brain.
                            @WhatTheFFacts: Studies show that sarcasm enhances the ability of the human mind to solve complex problems!

                            Comment

                            • vnzla81
                              Member
                              • Jul 2008
                              • 68174

                              Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                              RG3 just isn't big enough to sustain that kind of beating in the way Michael Vick hasn't been.
                              RG3 is bigger than Vick, Vick is like what 5'11" 210 pounds? RG3 is like 6'3" 225 pounds and I expect him to get bigger, he'll be fine.
                              @WhatTheFFacts: Studies show that sarcasm enhances the ability of the human mind to solve complex problems!

                              Comment

                              • xBulletproof
                                I have a Member
                                • Jun 2010
                                • 4671

                                Re: Luck vs Griffin - let it begin.

                                Originally posted by vnzla81
                                RG3 is bigger than Vick, Vick is like what 5'11" 210 pounds? RG3 is like 6'3" 225 pounds and I expect him to get bigger, he'll be fine.
                                It's about how you carry that weight, not just the numbers. Watch him on the field. He doesn't look any bigger than Vick.

                                Comment

                                Working...