As everyone knows, Peck and I have been arguing back and forth about Jeff Foster for quite awhile now. But lately several other posters, who I have a lot of respect for, have also been arguing with me about Jeff.
So I want everyone who cares to give an opinion on Jeff to do so in this thread.
I'm beginning to think maybe I need to take another look at Foster.
First, let me explain what my opinion of Jeff is.
Foster is my second favorite player on the Pacers team, I freely admit that and I'm not ashamed of that. Jeff is a role player, no question about that, he has problems scoring, is not a good shooter and overall does not bring much to the Pacers offensively, except offensive rebounds and the willingness to pass the ball to others and to get out of the way. Although he has scored a few times in the low post and has even hit a few jumpers. His free throw shooting is average for a big guy, 64%.
The next big problem some of you have about him is he is not very "big". can't argue with that, he will never overpower anyone, and he gets overpowered from time to time.
I guess I'm trying to say, I know his faults, and if the Pacers get a player who is better than Jeff, I would be in favor of taking Jeff out of the starting and finishing lineups. But I'm positive about one thing, none of the possible replacements, DH, Cro, Pollard are right now better than Jeff.
Let me also say I think Jeff should play right at 25 minutes per game, his talents are maximized when he lays 25 minutes per game.
You might be asking yourself why do you like him so much, all you've done is criticize Jeff, just trying to be balanced and demonstrate that I have a balanced opinion of the player.
In order of importance.
1) Foster is an energy player. You say big whoop, anyone can be an energy player. Not true. It takes talent to be an energy player, and it is more involved than "just playing hard". The effect that these type of players have on the whole team is very had to quantify, and you really don't notice it until they'll gone
2) Foster's defense. This is where I get into some trouble. I think Jeff is a very good defender. No, he won't make either of the NBA all defensive teams, but he is not too far from making that team. Yes, Jeff struggles against the really big players, such as Shaq, Z, and a few others. But for 90% of the players he guards he does a great job.
I loved watching a play on Sunday, somehow Jeff was switched out on Earl Watson, you could sense that Earl thought, well I'll just go right around Jeff, well he tried twice and could not do it so Earl finally passed to someone else. Earl tried once, and then backed out and tried again, and he could not beat Jeff off the dribble. Don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting Jeff start guarding small forward, SG or PG. But Jeff's quick hands and feet enables him to defend players very well. Many of you don't se this, but I'm just glad that Rick and Mike Brown see this.
3) Rebounding - won't say much about this. Jeff is great at blocking out, but no he is not going to overpower anyone, and no he is not great at getting the tough rebounds by going through people.
Let me end by addressing to arguments that have come up lately.
1) Jeff is of no use against the Heat or the Pistons. Afterall, wasn't Jeff replaced by Cro and then Al in the final games of the series against the Pistons. (brings back memories of how little Brad played in the last few games of the Celtics series the year before) Jeff defends Sheed very well, better than anyone else on the roster, so I don't buy the argument that he is of no use against the Pistons. Against the Heat, well no one can guard Shaq, Pollard does a better job, and we have not seen DH guard him yet.
2) J.O. needs a big strong big guy to play alongside him. I tend to agree that a big strong player next to J.O might be better, especially without Ron and AL. Keep in mind I predicted that DH will replace Jeff at some point next season if DH can get into NBA shape, but I'll also say DH has a long way to go. However 90% of the time Jeff is the perfect complement to J.O. on the defensive end.
Sorry, I've droned on and on, but I do want your opinions of Jeff
So I want everyone who cares to give an opinion on Jeff to do so in this thread.
I'm beginning to think maybe I need to take another look at Foster.
First, let me explain what my opinion of Jeff is.
Foster is my second favorite player on the Pacers team, I freely admit that and I'm not ashamed of that. Jeff is a role player, no question about that, he has problems scoring, is not a good shooter and overall does not bring much to the Pacers offensively, except offensive rebounds and the willingness to pass the ball to others and to get out of the way. Although he has scored a few times in the low post and has even hit a few jumpers. His free throw shooting is average for a big guy, 64%.
The next big problem some of you have about him is he is not very "big". can't argue with that, he will never overpower anyone, and he gets overpowered from time to time.
I guess I'm trying to say, I know his faults, and if the Pacers get a player who is better than Jeff, I would be in favor of taking Jeff out of the starting and finishing lineups. But I'm positive about one thing, none of the possible replacements, DH, Cro, Pollard are right now better than Jeff.
Let me also say I think Jeff should play right at 25 minutes per game, his talents are maximized when he lays 25 minutes per game.
You might be asking yourself why do you like him so much, all you've done is criticize Jeff, just trying to be balanced and demonstrate that I have a balanced opinion of the player.
In order of importance.
1) Foster is an energy player. You say big whoop, anyone can be an energy player. Not true. It takes talent to be an energy player, and it is more involved than "just playing hard". The effect that these type of players have on the whole team is very had to quantify, and you really don't notice it until they'll gone
2) Foster's defense. This is where I get into some trouble. I think Jeff is a very good defender. No, he won't make either of the NBA all defensive teams, but he is not too far from making that team. Yes, Jeff struggles against the really big players, such as Shaq, Z, and a few others. But for 90% of the players he guards he does a great job.
I loved watching a play on Sunday, somehow Jeff was switched out on Earl Watson, you could sense that Earl thought, well I'll just go right around Jeff, well he tried twice and could not do it so Earl finally passed to someone else. Earl tried once, and then backed out and tried again, and he could not beat Jeff off the dribble. Don't get me wrong, I'm not suggesting Jeff start guarding small forward, SG or PG. But Jeff's quick hands and feet enables him to defend players very well. Many of you don't se this, but I'm just glad that Rick and Mike Brown see this.
3) Rebounding - won't say much about this. Jeff is great at blocking out, but no he is not going to overpower anyone, and no he is not great at getting the tough rebounds by going through people.
Let me end by addressing to arguments that have come up lately.
1) Jeff is of no use against the Heat or the Pistons. Afterall, wasn't Jeff replaced by Cro and then Al in the final games of the series against the Pistons. (brings back memories of how little Brad played in the last few games of the Celtics series the year before) Jeff defends Sheed very well, better than anyone else on the roster, so I don't buy the argument that he is of no use against the Pistons. Against the Heat, well no one can guard Shaq, Pollard does a better job, and we have not seen DH guard him yet.
2) J.O. needs a big strong big guy to play alongside him. I tend to agree that a big strong player next to J.O might be better, especially without Ron and AL. Keep in mind I predicted that DH will replace Jeff at some point next season if DH can get into NBA shape, but I'll also say DH has a long way to go. However 90% of the time Jeff is the perfect complement to J.O. on the defensive end.
Sorry, I've droned on and on, but I do want your opinions of Jeff
Comment