So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • count55
    100 Miles from the B
    • Jun 2007
    • 5773

    #1

    So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

    This is Part 2 of my Draft Analysis. If you want to revisit the methodology and explanation, follow this link:



    For the second installment, I'm taking a closer look at the history of the 13th pick. As with the previous, I based my analysis on the draft classes 1982 through 2007. Since one of our first round draft picks, Brandon Rush, was taken with the 13th pick, I thought I'd look a little closer at that draft position.

    First, let's look back at my synopsis on the 12-17 picks grouping:

    Originally posted by count55
    Picks 12 to 17 - (156 picks since 1982, 155 played)

    The Accolades

    Rookie Awards - There have been no Rookies of the Year during this time frame. About 15% of the players taken between 12 and 17 were named to either the 1st or 2nd rookie team.

    All Star Appearances - 16 draftees in this group, or about 10%, have been named to at least one All-Star Game. 10 (6%) have made multiple appearances.

    All NBA Teams - Only about 6% (10) of this group have been named to at least one All NBA Team (1st, 2nd, or 3rd). Eight of these (5%) have earned this honor multiple times.

    All Defense Teams - Just seven players in this group (5%) have been named to All Defense team (1st, 2nd, or 3rd), all of them earning multiple mentions.

    Individual Awards - Though this is clearly an incomplete sample, Clyde Drexler is the only player that has already been inducted into the Hall of Fame.

    Surprisingly, three players (Kobe Bryant, Steve Nash, and Karl Malone) have been named league MVP. Our beloved Ron-Ron is the lone Defensive Player of the Year. There have been three Sixth Man of the Years (Dell Curry, Aaron McKie, and Corliss Williamson), and five Most Improved Players (Dana Barros, Jalen Rose, Alan Henderson, Jermaine O'Neal, and Hedo Turkoglu). There have been no Finals MVP.

    Production Groups

    Code:
    1. Group 1	1.3%
    2. Grp 2	3.2%
    3. Grp 3	11.0%
    4. Grp 4	27.1%
    5. Grp 5	31.6%
    6. Grp 6	25.8%
    Picks 13 - (26 picks since 1982, 26 played)

    The Accolades

    Rookie Awards - There have been no Rookies of the Year during this time frame. About 23% of #13's were named to either the 1st or 2nd rookie team, compared to 15% of all players taken between 12 and 17.

    All Star Appearances - 4 draftees (Kobe Bryant, Karl Malone, Dale Davis, & Sleepy Floyd) in this group, or about 15%, have been named to at least one All-Star Game. 2 (8%, Bryant & Malone) have made multiple appearances.

    All NBA Teams - Only about 8% (2, Kobe Bryant & Karl Malone) of this group have been named to at least one All NBA Team (1st, 2nd, or 3rd). Both of these have earned this honor multiple times.

    All Defense Teams - Just two players in this group (8%, Kobe Bryant & Karl Malone) have been named to All Defense team (1st, 2nd, or 3rd), all of them earning multiple mentions.

    Individual Awards - Though this is clearly an incomplete sample, no players have been inducted to the Hall of Fame from this group. Clearly, however, Karl Malone and Kobe Bryant are sure-fire HOFer's.

    Unsurprisingly, Kobe Bryant and Karl Malone have been named league MVP. There have been no Defensive Players of the Year, but Corliss Williamson earned Sixth Man of the Year, and Jalen Rose (with the Pacers) nabbed a Most Improved Player award. There have been no Finals MVP.

    Production Groups

    Code:
    1. Group 1	7.7%
    2. Grp 2	0.0%
    3. Grp 3	19.2%
    4. Grp 4	30.8%
    5. Grp 5	30.8%
    6. Grp 6	11.5%
    Here are the Group 1 (the stars) and Group 5 & 6 players...(the flops):

    Group 1: Karl Malone, Kobe Bryant

    Group 5: Thabo Sefolosha, Marcus Banks, Jeff Grayer, Pearl Washington, Ennis Whatley, Joe Wolf, Julian Wright, Courtney Alexander

    Group 6: Sean May, Michael Smith, Marcus Haislip
    Conclusion on the #13

    There have been two pantheon players taken during this time frame @ 13: Karl Malone and Kobe Bryant. They certainly help the percentages, but they are most certainly outliers.

    There have been some good pros to be taken at 13 (Richard Jefferson, Sleepy Floyd, Dale Davis, Jay Humphries), but 92% of the players fell in to Group 3 or worse. Essentially, history says there's only a one in five chance of getting a Group 3 (Above Average, starting quality producer). Meanwhile, the chances of a flop are twice that.

    Brandon Rush, the #13, and Rookie Production

    The other thing I wanted to look at here is to see what kind of production this slot has given during the rookie year. While my overall sample had 26 years of draft class, I only had access to the game logs from the 1986-1987 season forward. Therefore the following analysis only has 23 in the sample.

    It should be noted that the four players that were excluded (Sleepy Floyd, Ennis Whatley, Jay Humphries, and Karl Malone) were very productive players as rookies. In fact, Karl Malone had the highest AdjPR in the sample at 15.94, while Ennis Whatley's 12.78 would've been higher than anyone else in this sample. However, I wanted to track YTD production and show trends, and that data was not available to me.

    So, with a series of Charts, I'm going to show you what the #13 looks like:

    The Top 5 Players: 1. Jalen Rose (Den95); 2. Derek Anderson (Cle98); 3. Richard Jefferson (NJN02); 4. Dale Davis (Ind92); 5. Pearl Washington (NJN87)



    The Bottom 5 Players (worst first): 1. Jeff Grayer (MIL89); 2. Marcus Haislip (MIL03); 3. Corliss Williamson (SAC96); 4. Sean May (CHA06); 5. Terry Dehere (94LAC)



    The Fizzlers (Players who started strong, but faded): Jeff Grayer (MIL89); Joe Wolf (LAC88); Loy Vaught (LAC91); Sean May (CHA06)



    Injuries played a huge role in three (Grayer, Wolf, & May), but Loy Vaught played in 73 games.

    The Hockey Sticks (Slow starts, but climbing at the end): Jalen Rose (Den95); Sebastian Telfair (Por05); Kobe Bryant (LAL97); Courtney Alexander (Dal&Was01)



    Now, obviously these are just rookie numbers. Pearl Washington had the 8th worst career among the 26 #13's sampled, while bottom five member Corliss Williamson became a Sixth MOY and a very productive player.

    After compiling this data, I rolled in Brandon Rush's production through December 15th (the Wizards game). The chart below shows Brandon's performance, along with the best and worst (for the season), as well as a couple of players of interest:



    Through last night, Brandon had played in 23 of 24 games for the Pacers, producing an AdjPR of 7.00. This is good for 9th among all #13's through 12/15 of their rookie year. If he stays at this level for his entire rookie season, he would finish right on the breaking point between Group 4 and Group 5, posting the 7th best season for #13's in the sample.

    Though Group 4 is not a dream, we should probably be pleased with this production out of the #13 slot. It is above the median for the group, and there's good reason to be optimistic about Brandon himself. Despite briefly losing his spot in the rotation, his almost 23 minutes per game is 7th among #13's. Also, in the two games since returning to his spot in the rotation, he's posted Player Rater numbers of 16 and 13 (after only getting double digits in 3 of his previous 21 games).

    This chart also shows a positive trend:



    This is definitely early, but it is something I expect to updated on a weekly or bi-weekly basis for the rest of the season. The upward trendline is a positive sign, but, as shown in the "Fizzlers" above, it proves nothing yet.

    As always, cold, hard numbers lack the ability to completely distill the qualities of a player. To this point, I've been very happy with Brandon Rush. I believe these numbers show him to be an above average #13 pick, and they cannot quantify what I consider to be one of his greatest strenghts: his on-the-ball defense.

    Within the next week, I will repeat this exercise for Roy and the #17 pick. Once this is established, I should be able to update this tracking for the two of them on a weekly or bi-weekly basis. (Assuming, of course, there's any interest in this.)
    Last edited by count55; 12-17-2008, 08:24 AM.
  • Placebo
    Member
    • Apr 2008
    • 357

    #2
    Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

    Count, this is fascinating stuff. Personally, I'd be really interested to see it on a consistent basis. Thank you very much for posting this...

    Comment

    • bballpacen
      PG is not a 4
      • Aug 2006
      • 1231

      #3
      Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

      You may want to get a copyright on this stuff... Good freakin work count...:highhorse:
      Abba Zaba, your my only friend.

      Comment

      • imawhat
        Bring Back David West
        • Aug 2006
        • 10889

        #4
        Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

        Keep 'em coming, great stuff.

        One interesting thing, as a sidenote, is that you can sort-of see the "rookie wall" on these graphs, between Feb./March. Probably more variables at this range of picks (i.e. playing time), but I bet a study of picks 1-4 would show a very good trend on that rookie wall. This could make for some unique research.
        Last edited by imawhat; 12-17-2008, 05:23 AM.

        Comment

        • penbert66
          Member
          • Oct 2004
          • 113

          #5
          Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

          good stuff

          Comment

          • Quis
            Banned
            • Nov 2006
            • 904

            #6
            Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

            At this point, a smartly-used top-5 pick is probably the best thing that could happen to this franchise.

            Comment

            • Haggard
              Order more copier toner.
              • Jul 2006
              • 498

              #7
              Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

              Wow, great post. really facinating stuff. Thanks for taking the time to chart this and post it.
              Haggard's Blog: Can't Buy a Basket. Covering the highs and lows of the NBL

              Comment

              • Anthem
                White and Nerdy
                • Jan 2004
                • 24482

                #8
                Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                Originally posted by Quis
                At this point, a smartly-used top-5 pick is probably the best thing that could happen to this franchise.
                Not just this franchise. Every franchise.

                And not just right now. Pretty much always.

                The difficulty is that well-run franchises don't get top-5 picks without trading for them.
                This space for rent.

                Comment

                • Major Cold
                  Gone to Twitter. Done he
                  • Feb 2006
                  • 11491

                  #9
                  Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                  Count I swear you have come to be my favorite poster on this forum.

                  Comment

                  • count55
                    100 Miles from the B
                    • Jun 2007
                    • 5773

                    #10
                    Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                    Originally posted by Quis
                    At this point, a smartly-used top-5 pick is probably the best thing that could happen to this franchise.
                    I don't disagree, but the post wasn't really about what we need so much as what we have.

                    Comment

                    • Quis
                      Banned
                      • Nov 2006
                      • 904

                      #11
                      Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                      Originally posted by Anthem
                      Not just this franchise. Every franchise.

                      And not just right now. Pretty much always.

                      The difficulty is that well-run franchises don't get top-5 picks without trading for them.

                      The problem with this statement is that it's often top-5 picks - or at least top-10 picks - that begin the process of turning poorly-ran franchises into well-ran franchises. That's where we're at now. We've proven we're bad enough to be in the top-5 pick discussions, no matter whether that's the fault of current or past decision makers. There's no point in denying it. Instead, do what I do - accept it and realize that if we play our cards right, this teams future can get a lot brighter in a hurry.

                      I'm sure I'll be badmouthed for this, probably even told I'm not a real fan - but I'd take an 07-08 record of 22-60 & O.J. Mayo over an 07-08 record of 36-46 & Brandon Rush any day of the week. And I'm starting to come around on Brandon.
                      Last edited by Quis; 12-17-2008, 11:14 AM.

                      Comment

                      • count55
                        100 Miles from the B
                        • Jun 2007
                        • 5773

                        #12
                        Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                        Here's an additional look at Brandon's numbers. In this chart, you can see both the trended YTD line and the individual game results.

                        Last edited by count55; 12-17-2008, 02:58 PM.

                        Comment

                        • Anthem
                          White and Nerdy
                          • Jan 2004
                          • 24482

                          #13
                          Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                          Originally posted by Quis
                          The problem with this statement is that it's often top-5 picks - or at least top-10 picks - that begin the process of turning poorly-ran franchises into well-ran franchises.
                          Statistically, I don't think that's true.
                          This space for rent.

                          Comment

                          • Dr. Goldfoot
                            Member
                            • Dec 2005
                            • 1430

                            #14
                            Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                            Either do I. Often times a team that finds itself picking in the top five has poor management & poor coaching to go along with lack of talent. There are some exceptions like when a injuries deplete the team for a season etc...

                            Hawks since '99-'00 season
                            1 1st round playoff exit
                            13 1st round picks
                            7 top tens
                            4 top fives
                            0 winning seasons


                            Bulls since last championship '97-'98
                            2 1st round playoff exits 1 semifinals
                            14 1st round picks
                            10 top tens
                            7 top fives
                            2 winning seasons ( one .500 season)

                            Warriors post 50 win season in '93-'94
                            1 playoff appearance
                            15 1st rounders
                            7 top tens
                            4 top fives
                            2 winning seasons

                            Clippers since the move from San Diego in '84
                            3 1st round exits 1 semifinal
                            34 1st round picks
                            19 top tens
                            10 top fives
                            2 winning season (one .500 season)
                            I'm in these bands
                            The Humans
                            Dr. Goldfoot
                            The Bar Brawlers
                            ME

                            Comment

                            • DrFife
                              Member
                              • May 2008
                              • 2384

                              #15
                              Re: So, What does a draft pick get ya? (Part 2 - Brandon, #13's, and the Rookie Year)

                              Love it, Count, love it! Thank you!

                              Again, more from me soon, but for now let me thread one of my "findings" into your research.

                              Although the metrics I use are somewhat different, let's say that each year all GMs had a crystal ball to see future rookie productions. Let's also say that, pick by pick, each GM selects the best player still available.

                              I know,

                              In other words, the value of the 13th pick is set equal to the average (over at least several years' worth of rookie classes) overall value of the 13th most productive rookie.

                              My analysis suggests that the 13th pick, then, has a predicted value of 290 for the first year, 210 for the second year and 165 for the third. Dividing by 30, we see a corresponding interpretation of 9th man as a rookie, 7th (or 8th) as a second-year player, and 6th as a third-year player; i.e., a strong rotation player with the potential to become a starter. IMO, Rush fits that description nicely.

                              Perhaps a fair summary statement to capture our comments is: "Drafting is doggone difficult; it is NOT an exact science and mistakes are all too common. Nevertheless, talent remains after the top players are chosen, and a reasonable expectation for a well-chosen selection at #13 is for that player to develop quickly into a productive rotation player."

                              I, too, will be delighted to see your (biweekly?) updates on Rush and Hibbert as the season progresses. Thanks again!
                              Last edited by DrFife; 12-17-2008, 02:46 PM. Reason: Legibility


                              "Heโ€™s no shrinking violet when it comes to that kind of stuff."

                              - Rick Carlisle on how Kevin Pritchard responds to needed roster changes.

                              Comment

                              Working...