Who is more successful over next 10 years? Dallas or Indiana

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Ichi
    Member
    • Feb 2012
    • 5069

    #46
    Originally posted by CJ Jones

    I mean he just had Brunson whose development he clearly stunted. I guess time will tell if you're right. I think he'll need to join a super team and change his game some to win a chip. I doubt that happens in Dallas anytime soon .
    I don't think that's accurate. Brunson just kept/keeps getting better with time. He peaked (so far) in the postseason that just happened. I'm sure he'll plateau sometime soon, but he's been climbing up the hill pretty steadily imo.

    Comment

    • CJ Jones
      Member
      • Jan 2012
      • 9259

      #47
      Originally posted by Dece


      So OF COURSE you'd take Luka over Hali.



      Except you think Luka is a loser? So I guess you think Hali is worse than a loser? You also said Luka is Harden 2.0, and you think Harden is a loser, despite him being winning more playoff games than the Pacers have appeared in over his career.



      You'd take Luka over Hali, but you wouldn't trade Hali for any other PG...Luka is a PG. So here you're saying you wouldn't take him but we just established you would. Are you just one of those dudes who says stuff without any sort of actual conviction behind it then, or what? I don't know, if these aren't the things you are trying to say you aren't doing a good job of representing yourself. That's not even going into the craziness of taking Hali over prime Harden.

      Anyway, we're pretty sidetracked from Dallas or Indiana over the next 10 years.
      What kinda weird **** is this? Do you really not understand what I meant by "in a vacuum" or are you just being purposefully obtuse? How am I contradicting myself by saying Luka's the better talent but Ty's the better player to build around in Indiana? I post mostly from my phone man, do I really need to spell out for you all the obvious reasons why Ty's a better fit here? How long do you think Luka stays if we somehow swapped him straight up for Ty? Some of you might risk any potential long term success for a small championship window now, but I personally wouldn't bet on this version of Luka. His lack of conditioning is a well known weakness. If you're blowing that off like it's a non factor, I'd question how much you pay attention to the league. Even Mavs fans will tell you it's a problem.

      My position is really not that far off from others that voted Pacers. The word loser is just harsher than using the phrase "not a winning player". And again, all things considered (long term viability, player control, maturity, leadership, midwest living, etc., etc.) I'm taking my chances with Ty over Luka and it makes perfect sense as long as your head's not up your *** . Alright we can move on now.

      Comment

      • CJ Jones
        Member
        • Jan 2012
        • 9259

        #48
        Originally posted by Wage

        I'm not saying Rick always sucked, I'm saying he sucks now. It happens to the best of em. If Luka or Harden go 10 years without a playoff series win then I won't call you on saying they are losers now. Promise.




        Yeaaa I'm still not seeing the distinction here. You think my take here on Harden/Luka is bizarre, and I think your take on Rick is bizarre. These are literally the exact same things. The 10 year playoff drought you talk about is almost meaningless to me. It's cool, we just value some things differently.

        Comment

        • CJ Jones
          Member
          • Jan 2012
          • 9259

          #49
          Originally posted by Ichi

          I don't think that's accurate. Brunson just kept/keeps getting better with time. He peaked (so far) in the postseason that just happened. I'm sure he'll plateau sometime soon, but he's been climbing up the hill pretty steadily imo.
          Eh, he jumped up eight points per game though. That's a lot. You think that happens if he's still in Dallas? I don't. His usage went way up last season because he was finally the primary ball handler. That never happens if he stays in Dallas. I'd assume he's very happy to be out from under Luka's shadow.

          Comment

          • Wage
            Member
            • May 2008
            • 2583

            #50
            Originally posted by CJ Jones


            Yeaaa I'm still not seeing the distinction here. You think my take here on Harden/Luka is bizarre, and I think your take on Rick is bizarre. These are literally the exact same things. The 10 year playoff drought you talk about is almost meaningless to me. It's cool, we just value some things differently.
            Yeah if you think a 10 year playoff drought is meaningless then we definitely value different things. I'd be curious what the heck you are going to use to define a successful season to answer the posed question. Guess it isn't playoff success so what then?

            Comment

            • CJ Jones
              Member
              • Jan 2012
              • 9259

              #51
              Originally posted by Wage

              Yeah if you think a 10 year playoff drought is meaningless then we definitely value different things. I'd be curious what the heck you are going to use to define a successful season to answer the posed question. Guess it isn't playoff success so what then?
              Get this team into the top 10 offensively. It's as simple as that. We haven't been that high in maybe 20 years. We may not make it there this season but I think Rick and Hali together will get us there in the near future.

              Comment

              • Wage
                Member
                • May 2008
                • 2583

                #52
                Originally posted by CJ Jones

                Get this team into the top 10 offensively. It's as simple as that. We haven't been that high in maybe 20 years. We may not make it there this season but I think Rick and Hali together will get us there in the near future.
                So a top 10 offense on a trash team is a successful season? Post season success be damned? Got it. Yeah we have different priorities here. Give me the 30th ranked offense and a championship please.

                Comment

                • Ichi
                  Member
                  • Feb 2012
                  • 5069

                  #53
                  Originally posted by CJ Jones

                  Eh, he jumped up eight points per game though. That's a lot. You think that happens if he's still in Dallas? I don't. His usage went way up last season because he was finally the primary ball handler. That never happens if he stays in Dallas. I'd assume he's very happy to be out from under Luka's shadow.
                  Yeah, I do agree with you that his usage grew, and he scored more, and still very efficiently. I do think he would have gotten an extra shot or two each game, but not the extra 5ish shots he ended up getting in NY. I don't think Luka held him back, he was just still growing into the guy he has become, even if he didn't have quite as many shots/points. I think it's hard to fault a point guard when another point guard on the roster doesn't get the ball as much as they probably should. Especially since they both do a lot of damage from similar areas on the court.

                  Comment

                  • CJ Jones
                    Member
                    • Jan 2012
                    • 9259

                    #54
                    Originally posted by Wage

                    So a top 10 offense on a trash team is a successful season? Post season success be damned? Got it. Yeah we have different priorities here. Give me the 30th ranked offense and a championship please.
                    Me too if that was possible but a top 10 offense is basically a requirement to win a title. That's precisely why it's about all I care about right now, and really has been since I noticed the trend a long time ago. They'll eventually have to be an average defensive team to be serious contenders, but I'll worry about that and his playoff performance later. One step at a time.

                    Comment

                    Working...