Donatos-But they are way too expensive, and their online coupons are almost worthless. Plus the location by our house has just constantly screwed up our order, or better yet, completely forgot to make that damn thing. So we have implemented a family boycott on that Donatos Location so therefore we dont' eat Donatos. But in general their Pizza when made right is great.
Papa Johns - typically a good pizza, always have a good deal that lets us get a large 5 topping and a cheese bread for under $20. Not too greasy either.
Marcos - I wanted to love them, the big square deal is a good. We probably ate there exclusively for a year (pizza wise). But their pizza is just soaked in grease, and you just get tired of that. I just a good pizza on the amount of grease that collects on top and on the paper mat inside the box.
PizzaHut, I honestly just don't trust them. Everything there tastes pre-packaged. Its greasy, the kitchen never looks clean.
Some Guys: Our current fav. Can be very expensive if you order it your way, but if you stay on menu and just order one of their combinations you can do a bit better. We get the Classic Pizza (pepperoni, sausage, mushroom) its a damn good pizza they put some Fontina and Mozzerella cheese blend. They square cut it here, its thin crust, but not too thin, and Good basic Garlic Bread.
Bazbeux? - yes I like them, probably the best gourmet pizza i've ever had. Love the Tuna and Ricotta pizza, and thats the problem with them. I like their unique combinations, and my wife does not. I'm not paying that price for a standard pizza. Plus I can never find parking in Broadripple to go pick it up. Same with Hotbox who I hear is good, but they only have on street parking so literally picking up a pizza becomes a hassle. so I've not bothered to try them.