I think point guards do affect the game, but at some point it starts to become diminishing returns into the total impact of the game, I don't know it's a tough question. I'm a sucker for point guards because my favorite thing to do when playing ball is setting people up to score, so I lean towards liking them more. Like I've said since page 1, Paul's evolution as a creator over the last 15-20 games is what has moved him in front of Kyrie for me, in just my humblest of opinions, and by a slight margin. Heck in February, they are averaging the same amount of assists. Kyrie is the better scorer. Paul is the much better defender. Paul is the better rebounder, but Kyrie is not bad on the boards for a point.
Like has been said multiple times, it's just amazing we're able to actually discuss Paul alongside Kyrie right now. Never would have guessed that four months ago. Kyrie is still my favorite young player in the league that is not on the P's and it's amazing to have a guy that can stand in the same breath as him.