It doesn't matter what Luck had or didn't have at his disposal. It matters what kind of stats he put up. RGIII put up great stats. I fully expect that Luck in the long term will close the gap or be even better than RG but ROY goes to one of the other two. I will trade two wins in the playoffs for the ROY any day.
We beat the team that just beat the Bengals. I'm excited about tomorrow.