Mayor Ballard is initiating a campaign that will seek to lower the number of panhandlers downtown. I came up to Indy from Bloomington on Saturday night to visit downtown. It's a great little downtown, with the mass of restaurants and entertainment, and you feel safe because there are a lot of people down there up until a pretty late hour.
But one thing that bothered me was the amount of people trying to hit me up for change. I don't have a big problem if someone just sits with a bucket without saying anything, but most of these people were borderline harassing pedestrians. I was trying to have a nice evening with my girlfriend, and was a little irked to be bothered on every corner for change, which was then followed by a smart-ellic remark when I ignored them. I think people who want to spend time downtown and who are filtering money into the Indy economy shouldn't have to deal with this.
I support the mayor's plan. Here is an article from the star today.
http://www.indystar.com/apps/pbcs.dl...316/-1/ARCHIVE
Mayor seeks to rid streets of panhandlers
Ballard's plan includes campaign to encourage people to give to charities instead of cup-shakers
By Brendan O'Shaughnessy
Posted: March 31, 2008
* Read Comments(78)
* Recommend (7)
* E-mail
* Print
* Share
o del.icio.us Del.icio.us
o Digg Digg
o Reddit Reddit
o Yahoo Yahoo
o Google Google
*
A
A
Mayor Greg Ballard wants to sweep Downtown streets clean of panhandlers such as Chris Hall.
Hall, 33, slumped against a newspaper vending box Friday on Monument Circle, bundled in a thick jacket with a half-full cup of change and a sign saying he is homeless. He said he has pulled in $20 or $30 by panhandling about three hours per day for the past eight or nine years on and off.
Advertisement
John Cochran, Ballard's special counsel, said the Mayor's Action Center receives complaints and the mayor's staff hears about panhandling regularly.
"People who live Downtown are tired of it," Cochran said. "We want to reduce it to a palatable level."
To do that, Ballard wants to bring a "tough love" approach to the issue.
He said people shouldn't feel constantly harassed to give money.
"The immediate goal is to get them out of Downtown so that citizens and visitors don't have to look at it," Ballard said last week.
His three-pronged plan will include:
A public awareness campaign to encourage people to give to homeless charities instead of cup-shakers.
More aggressive enforcement of current laws.
Possibly requiring a pricey license to try to regulate panhandlers the same way the city does hot dog vendors.
The mayor, whom Democrats accused of being insensitive on the topic during his campaign, said homeless advocates also want to curb donations, which can foster dependency instead of change.
"They're not all homeless," Ballard said. "Panhandlers are a sham. I think most people know that."
Andrea De Mink Kaufmann, executive director of The PourHouse, an Indianapolis homeless advocacy group, said aggressive, professional panhandlers do give the others a bad name.
"But if someone is sitting there quietly, that's their right," Kaufmann said. "To say it's ugly and we want it out of view, I have an issue with that from a humanitarian point of view."
Hall said he doesn't think it's fair to harass him when he doesn't bother anyone.
"Just because someone's down and out doesn't mean you should arrest them," he said. "There's always going to be someone on the streets no matter what the mayor does."
Hall said he doesn't like pushy panhandlers, either, because they ruin it for others.
Cochran, who is leading the panhandling effort for the mayor, plans to hold a focus group Friday with local nonprofits and government agencies involved with the homeless.
"We've been looking at what other jurisdictions do and considering increased regulation," he said. "Cincinnati requires panhandlers to have a license that costs $400. It seems to be effective in decreasing the numbers."
The mayor's office will help coordinate a public awareness campaign being conducted by the Coalition for Homelessness Intervention and Prevention and Indianapolis Downtown Inc., two nonprofits that recently received Lilly Endowment grants for that purpose.
"We ask people to redirect their charitable instinct to charities as opposed to giving to those on the street, which can perpetuate that lifestyle," said Jennifer Hunt, CHIP's development director.
The mayor's plan should receive strong support from the Garfield Neighbors Neighborhood Association. Recent meetings have featured residents of the Southside neighborhood complaining to city police officers about panhandlers who camp out at the Raymond Street exit off I-65.
"I don't like to see the same guys there begging every day," said Julie Dolen, the association president. "It gives a bad image. They break into garages to sleep and contribute to petty crime."
Soliciting a stopped vehicle is among the activities made illegal under city code in 1999. Other revisions include prohibiting asking for money at night, aggressive actions such as touching or following and soliciting within 20 feet of an ATM or bus stop. The state passed a similar criminal law in 2005.
A spokesman for the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department said there isn't a full-time unit charged with enforcing the panhandling law. There apparently was a special unit in 2002, but Sgt. Paul Thompson of the IMPD said neighborhood resource officers now handle complaints.
The department has received 11 complaints so far this year, and the vice squad does occasional sweeps, Thompson said. But tickets don't do much good.
"They don't pay because they have no reason to," he said. "Typically, they don't have credit or a license, so you're not getting any money out of them."
Tom Goins, 64, said he and his guitar have been a fixture Downtown for 18 years. Passers-by dropped coins into his guitar case as he went through his repertoire of golden oldies Friday.
Goins said he has a home on the Eastside and earns money as a busker, playing music for money. He hopes the mayor's plan will make a distinction between busking and panhandling.
"Those cup-shakers really make money," Goins said. "They make more than me but I don't begrudge them. They got their own problems."
Call Star reporter Brendan O'Shaughnessy at (317) 444-2751.
But one thing that bothered me was the amount of people trying to hit me up for change. I don't have a big problem if someone just sits with a bucket without saying anything, but most of these people were borderline harassing pedestrians. I was trying to have a nice evening with my girlfriend, and was a little irked to be bothered on every corner for change, which was then followed by a smart-ellic remark when I ignored them. I think people who want to spend time downtown and who are filtering money into the Indy economy shouldn't have to deal with this.
I support the mayor's plan. Here is an article from the star today.
http://www.indystar.com/apps/pbcs.dl...316/-1/ARCHIVE
Mayor seeks to rid streets of panhandlers
Ballard's plan includes campaign to encourage people to give to charities instead of cup-shakers
By Brendan O'Shaughnessy
Posted: March 31, 2008
* Read Comments(78)
* Recommend (7)
* Share
o del.icio.us Del.icio.us
o Digg Digg
o Reddit Reddit
o Yahoo Yahoo
o Google Google
*
A
A
Mayor Greg Ballard wants to sweep Downtown streets clean of panhandlers such as Chris Hall.
Hall, 33, slumped against a newspaper vending box Friday on Monument Circle, bundled in a thick jacket with a half-full cup of change and a sign saying he is homeless. He said he has pulled in $20 or $30 by panhandling about three hours per day for the past eight or nine years on and off.
Advertisement
John Cochran, Ballard's special counsel, said the Mayor's Action Center receives complaints and the mayor's staff hears about panhandling regularly.
"People who live Downtown are tired of it," Cochran said. "We want to reduce it to a palatable level."
To do that, Ballard wants to bring a "tough love" approach to the issue.
He said people shouldn't feel constantly harassed to give money.
"The immediate goal is to get them out of Downtown so that citizens and visitors don't have to look at it," Ballard said last week.
His three-pronged plan will include:
A public awareness campaign to encourage people to give to homeless charities instead of cup-shakers.
More aggressive enforcement of current laws.
Possibly requiring a pricey license to try to regulate panhandlers the same way the city does hot dog vendors.
The mayor, whom Democrats accused of being insensitive on the topic during his campaign, said homeless advocates also want to curb donations, which can foster dependency instead of change.
"They're not all homeless," Ballard said. "Panhandlers are a sham. I think most people know that."
Andrea De Mink Kaufmann, executive director of The PourHouse, an Indianapolis homeless advocacy group, said aggressive, professional panhandlers do give the others a bad name.
"But if someone is sitting there quietly, that's their right," Kaufmann said. "To say it's ugly and we want it out of view, I have an issue with that from a humanitarian point of view."
Hall said he doesn't think it's fair to harass him when he doesn't bother anyone.
"Just because someone's down and out doesn't mean you should arrest them," he said. "There's always going to be someone on the streets no matter what the mayor does."
Hall said he doesn't like pushy panhandlers, either, because they ruin it for others.
Cochran, who is leading the panhandling effort for the mayor, plans to hold a focus group Friday with local nonprofits and government agencies involved with the homeless.
"We've been looking at what other jurisdictions do and considering increased regulation," he said. "Cincinnati requires panhandlers to have a license that costs $400. It seems to be effective in decreasing the numbers."
The mayor's office will help coordinate a public awareness campaign being conducted by the Coalition for Homelessness Intervention and Prevention and Indianapolis Downtown Inc., two nonprofits that recently received Lilly Endowment grants for that purpose.
"We ask people to redirect their charitable instinct to charities as opposed to giving to those on the street, which can perpetuate that lifestyle," said Jennifer Hunt, CHIP's development director.
The mayor's plan should receive strong support from the Garfield Neighbors Neighborhood Association. Recent meetings have featured residents of the Southside neighborhood complaining to city police officers about panhandlers who camp out at the Raymond Street exit off I-65.
"I don't like to see the same guys there begging every day," said Julie Dolen, the association president. "It gives a bad image. They break into garages to sleep and contribute to petty crime."
Soliciting a stopped vehicle is among the activities made illegal under city code in 1999. Other revisions include prohibiting asking for money at night, aggressive actions such as touching or following and soliciting within 20 feet of an ATM or bus stop. The state passed a similar criminal law in 2005.
A spokesman for the Indianapolis Metropolitan Police Department said there isn't a full-time unit charged with enforcing the panhandling law. There apparently was a special unit in 2002, but Sgt. Paul Thompson of the IMPD said neighborhood resource officers now handle complaints.
The department has received 11 complaints so far this year, and the vice squad does occasional sweeps, Thompson said. But tickets don't do much good.
"They don't pay because they have no reason to," he said. "Typically, they don't have credit or a license, so you're not getting any money out of them."
Tom Goins, 64, said he and his guitar have been a fixture Downtown for 18 years. Passers-by dropped coins into his guitar case as he went through his repertoire of golden oldies Friday.
Goins said he has a home on the Eastside and earns money as a busker, playing music for money. He hopes the mayor's plan will make a distinction between busking and panhandling.
"Those cup-shakers really make money," Goins said. "They make more than me but I don't begrudge them. They got their own problems."
Call Star reporter Brendan O'Shaughnessy at (317) 444-2751.
Comment