I disagree here.
Jermaine is a star but not what I like to call a unreplacable star.
Reggie was that guy. Reggie was the face of the franchise. When you think Indiana Pacers you still probably think Reggie Miller. Winning was associated with Reggie here.
Can't say the same about Jermaine. I wouldn't call him a fan favorite on the same level as Reggie was. Nothing against Jermaine but it's just different.