I know I said I was tired of the Carlisle vs Pistons stories, but reading what the Pistons players are evidently saying behind his back, I am a littel steamed. Maybe George Irvine should have coached the Pistons the past two years, they would nopt have stiffed the playoffs then, and maybe they would not be so spolied.
here are a series of articles on this topic.
http://www.freep.com/sports/pistons/drew22_20040522.htm
DREW SHARP: In their minds: Pistons would have revolted
May 22, 2004
BY DREW SHARP
FREE PRESS COLUMNIST
Happily emancipated, those Pistons most disenchanted with Rick Carlisle's distrusting approach could have eagerly shoveled dirt over his freshly dug coaching grave. But team president Joe Dumars handed down the strict edict immediately after kicking Carlisle to the curb following consecutive 50-victory and divisional championship seasons.
He didn't want to hear one detractive whisper regarding Carlisle, not wanting to make the perception any worse for the coach than it already was on the players' underground communications network.
Let it go and move forward.
But it's a year later and the particulars surrounding Carlisle's ouster have assumed urban legend status, a mystery with as many answers as Loch Ness monster sightings. It's the primary subplot to these Eastern Conference finals and as much as players casually dismiss the talk as a figment of media overreaction, it's evident that strong feelings remain.
"Miss him?" Ben Wallace said. "Why should I miss him?"
So, Ben, do any of the other guys miss him?
"No."
Tell us how you really feel, big fella.
Chauncey Billups prefaced almost all response to questions regarding his former coach with the pat "Rick and I got along fine."
When the interrogation pointedly turned toward any player involvement in Carlisle's dismissal, Billups tried deflecting attention from the locker room, saying that he "wasn't the general manager."
Dumars pulled the trigger, but only after assessing that discontent over Carlisle's inflexibility in game management and generally poor communicative skills created an environment ripe for team dissension.
The debate will rage on sports talk radio and Internet chat rooms throughout this series, but it's a moot argument.
Suggesting that the bonus prize of these Eastern Conference finals is concrete affirmation as to who should have coached the Pistons this season is idiotic. The answer should have been clear long ago for the Carlisle-nistas with their heels stubbornly entrenched. He would not have lasted beyond Christmas before a players revolt relaunched his television career and left the Pistons with no other alternative but to elevate an assistant coach to an interim post.
This wasn't an issue about Carlisle dissing his owner or not cooperating with the team's marketing department or needlessly treating organizational subordinates like garbage.
This was a breakdown between coach and players and although it's convenient to assail pampered millionaires for their selfishness, the realities of NBA coaching is that control has its limits. You can teach and torment to the point of suffocation, but eventually a coach must cut the cord and trust his players' instincts and their willingness to incorporate the lessons imparted upon them.
Carlisle wanted to script every second of a 48-minute game. Perhaps that's necessary in football, but the NBA demands some degree of spontaneity. But that requires trust and the bottom line was that Carlisle didn't trust his players to balance what coaches want them to do with what they know they need to do.
And few things are more insulting to the highly skilled professional athlete.
"I'm not getting into all that," Big Ben added. "That's for all of y'all to talk about. He's not our coach anymore. He's with the other team. And we're trying to beat him to get to the NBA Finals. That's all."
One difference between Carlisle and Larry Brown was evident in the first quarter of Game 7 against New Jersey. Could you imagine Ben Wallace feeling comfortable enough in the half-court offense to take mid-range shots that the opposition gave him last year with Carlisle?
The two barely exchanged two words last season because Carlisle made it clear that he didn't trust Wallace's ability to become even a modest offensive contributor.
In Game 7, Wallace made eight of his 10 attempts from the floor, but more telling was that he wasn't averse to taking shots off the early open looks he got. He made all three of his field-goal attempts in the first quarter when the game's outcome remained in question.
They'll exchange handshakes and other cordialities, publicly assuring everyone that there's a singular focus on making the NBA Finals. But nobody's buying the pleasantries. The next two weeks will be defined as much by who's beaten as well as who won.
http://www.freep.com/sports/pistons/...2_20040522.htm
PERRY A. FARRELL: In their hearts: Pistons love it without Carlisle
May 22, 2004
BY PARRY FARRELL
FREE PRESS COLUMNIST
If you don't want to hear the truth in its rawest, purest form, don't ask Ben Wallace a question.
Ask someone who might be politically correct, like Chauncey Billups or Corliss Williamson or Richard Hamilton.
For that matter, don't ask Rasheed Wallace, either.
But a day before the biggest series in the Eastern Conference, which features more subplots than a weeklong airing of "General Hospital," Ben Wallace was asked whether he missed Rick Carlisle, the coach who guided the Pistons to 100 victories over the previous two seasons and a trip to the Eastern Conference finals.
Understand, the question was from a television reporter new to the scene and probably not wise to the ways of the tell-it-like-it-is Wallace.
In typical fashion, Wallace looked at the reporter and said, "I don't miss nobody. Why would I miss him?"
When it was suggested that perhaps he liked playing for Carlisle, Wallace replied: "I like playing basketball. I'd miss the game if it were taken away from me. Coaches and players come and go. I don't think I built that big of a bond with Coach Carlisle that I actually miss him."
When asked whether any of his teammates missed Carlisle, Wallace's reply was simple: "No, this is a business."
Then he added: "He's going to be excited, he's going to want to win, and we're the same way. We have pride. He has another job. We have another job to do. They're in our way, and we're trying to get a win."
Is that simple enough?
Understand that players are loyal to payday, their children, teammates, playing time and winning.
Ben Wallace's teammates said they didn't have a problem with Carlisle and they communicated with him when it was necessary, but once the organization decided to fire Carlisle and hire Larry Brown last summer, there was no outcry over why the coach that produced 100 victories in two seasons had been dismissed.
"I enjoy playing for Coach Brown," Hamilton said. "I think he has made the game fun for me at both ends of the floor. I'm satisfied with the situation here. I didn't have a problem with Rick. If there was something I needed to know I would go up and communicate with him and that was it. Last year was my first year with him and I was only with him for seven or eight months. He's a different guy. He's definitely different."
Ben Wallace, the Pistons' leader on the floor, had problems with Carlisle as far back as the first-round playoff series with Toronto in Carlisle's first year. Antonio Davis, a former Pacer, had a couple of good games to help tie the series at 2, and some comments were made that irritated Wallace. He won't elaborate, but he doesn't need to.
The two-time defensive player of the year finished second this season to Ron Artest in the coaches and media voting. Carlisle campaigned for Artest. When he was the Pistons' coach he made phone calls on Wallace's behalf.
Don't think losing his title as the best defender to Artest has been lost on Wallace, or the campaigning that helped pry it away from him.
Wallace was asked whom would he have picked if he had a vote for the award.
"You mean, if I couldn't vote for myself?" he said. "If I could vote for myself, I'd vote for myself. He'd probably be the next guy in line. The things he does at the defensive end really helps that team and gets that team going.
"Any time a great defender is looking at another defender, you're going to see some things similar to yourself. There aren't many guys who are going to take it upon themselves to go out and be a defender first and worry about the offense later."
But Billups said: "That's definitely motivation for him. Artest is a good defender, but I don't think he has the effect on the game defensively that Ben Wallace does. No way. No how. I know he'll be extra motivated for that. I want him to be aggressive. When he has the opportunity to take it (offensively), I want him to take it. I know defensively he's going to be out there to make a point."
Wallace, of course, is still a great defender, but his role has changed. Instead of standing in the corner and not getting in the way offensively under Carlisle, Wallace has been asked to take an active role.
"I watched tape of Indiana playing him, and they never guarded him," Brown said. "Toronto didn't guard him either, and that's Kevin O'Neill, who coached with Rick. I just think we need everybody to be aggressive offensively."
Joe Dumars, the Pistons' president of basketball operations, recalled how "we'd be out there 4-on-5 or 3-on-5 and it's tough to play like that," when he reflected on the offense under Carlisle.
"He has to take the shot and give us a chance," Dumars said. "Ron and Ben is another subplot. All the subplots are great, but I think they'll be secondary."
Because Carlisle coached most of this season's Pistons last season, Wallace was asked if that would help the Pacers.
"Rick hasn't coached this team," he said. "This is a different team. We've made a lot of changes. We've added a couple of guys and some guys' roles have changed, so we're different than when he was here."
No longer is Ben asked to stand in a corner and score off offensive rebounds or lob dunks. In Game 7 against New Jersey, he scored the Pistons' first two baskets and finished with 18 points on 8-for-10 shooting.
"Coming into this season, my mind was already made up that I was going to go out and take more chances and take more shots because the coaching staff encouraged me to go out there and take more chances and take more shots," Wallace said. "Coach has been in support of it."
And so have his teammates.
"He's the first one here and the last to leave," Billups said. "He shoots more than anybody. He can make those shots. It's just a matter of him becoming more comfortable. . . . He's not used to doing it in game situations, but you can see he's becoming more and more comfortable."
here are a series of articles on this topic.
http://www.freep.com/sports/pistons/drew22_20040522.htm
DREW SHARP: In their minds: Pistons would have revolted
May 22, 2004
BY DREW SHARP
FREE PRESS COLUMNIST
Happily emancipated, those Pistons most disenchanted with Rick Carlisle's distrusting approach could have eagerly shoveled dirt over his freshly dug coaching grave. But team president Joe Dumars handed down the strict edict immediately after kicking Carlisle to the curb following consecutive 50-victory and divisional championship seasons.
He didn't want to hear one detractive whisper regarding Carlisle, not wanting to make the perception any worse for the coach than it already was on the players' underground communications network.
Let it go and move forward.
But it's a year later and the particulars surrounding Carlisle's ouster have assumed urban legend status, a mystery with as many answers as Loch Ness monster sightings. It's the primary subplot to these Eastern Conference finals and as much as players casually dismiss the talk as a figment of media overreaction, it's evident that strong feelings remain.
"Miss him?" Ben Wallace said. "Why should I miss him?"
So, Ben, do any of the other guys miss him?
"No."
Tell us how you really feel, big fella.
Chauncey Billups prefaced almost all response to questions regarding his former coach with the pat "Rick and I got along fine."
When the interrogation pointedly turned toward any player involvement in Carlisle's dismissal, Billups tried deflecting attention from the locker room, saying that he "wasn't the general manager."
Dumars pulled the trigger, but only after assessing that discontent over Carlisle's inflexibility in game management and generally poor communicative skills created an environment ripe for team dissension.
The debate will rage on sports talk radio and Internet chat rooms throughout this series, but it's a moot argument.
Suggesting that the bonus prize of these Eastern Conference finals is concrete affirmation as to who should have coached the Pistons this season is idiotic. The answer should have been clear long ago for the Carlisle-nistas with their heels stubbornly entrenched. He would not have lasted beyond Christmas before a players revolt relaunched his television career and left the Pistons with no other alternative but to elevate an assistant coach to an interim post.
This wasn't an issue about Carlisle dissing his owner or not cooperating with the team's marketing department or needlessly treating organizational subordinates like garbage.
This was a breakdown between coach and players and although it's convenient to assail pampered millionaires for their selfishness, the realities of NBA coaching is that control has its limits. You can teach and torment to the point of suffocation, but eventually a coach must cut the cord and trust his players' instincts and their willingness to incorporate the lessons imparted upon them.
Carlisle wanted to script every second of a 48-minute game. Perhaps that's necessary in football, but the NBA demands some degree of spontaneity. But that requires trust and the bottom line was that Carlisle didn't trust his players to balance what coaches want them to do with what they know they need to do.
And few things are more insulting to the highly skilled professional athlete.
"I'm not getting into all that," Big Ben added. "That's for all of y'all to talk about. He's not our coach anymore. He's with the other team. And we're trying to beat him to get to the NBA Finals. That's all."
One difference between Carlisle and Larry Brown was evident in the first quarter of Game 7 against New Jersey. Could you imagine Ben Wallace feeling comfortable enough in the half-court offense to take mid-range shots that the opposition gave him last year with Carlisle?
The two barely exchanged two words last season because Carlisle made it clear that he didn't trust Wallace's ability to become even a modest offensive contributor.
In Game 7, Wallace made eight of his 10 attempts from the floor, but more telling was that he wasn't averse to taking shots off the early open looks he got. He made all three of his field-goal attempts in the first quarter when the game's outcome remained in question.
They'll exchange handshakes and other cordialities, publicly assuring everyone that there's a singular focus on making the NBA Finals. But nobody's buying the pleasantries. The next two weeks will be defined as much by who's beaten as well as who won.
http://www.freep.com/sports/pistons/...2_20040522.htm
PERRY A. FARRELL: In their hearts: Pistons love it without Carlisle
May 22, 2004
BY PARRY FARRELL
FREE PRESS COLUMNIST
If you don't want to hear the truth in its rawest, purest form, don't ask Ben Wallace a question.
Ask someone who might be politically correct, like Chauncey Billups or Corliss Williamson or Richard Hamilton.
For that matter, don't ask Rasheed Wallace, either.
But a day before the biggest series in the Eastern Conference, which features more subplots than a weeklong airing of "General Hospital," Ben Wallace was asked whether he missed Rick Carlisle, the coach who guided the Pistons to 100 victories over the previous two seasons and a trip to the Eastern Conference finals.
Understand, the question was from a television reporter new to the scene and probably not wise to the ways of the tell-it-like-it-is Wallace.
In typical fashion, Wallace looked at the reporter and said, "I don't miss nobody. Why would I miss him?"
When it was suggested that perhaps he liked playing for Carlisle, Wallace replied: "I like playing basketball. I'd miss the game if it were taken away from me. Coaches and players come and go. I don't think I built that big of a bond with Coach Carlisle that I actually miss him."
When asked whether any of his teammates missed Carlisle, Wallace's reply was simple: "No, this is a business."
Then he added: "He's going to be excited, he's going to want to win, and we're the same way. We have pride. He has another job. We have another job to do. They're in our way, and we're trying to get a win."
Is that simple enough?
Understand that players are loyal to payday, their children, teammates, playing time and winning.
Ben Wallace's teammates said they didn't have a problem with Carlisle and they communicated with him when it was necessary, but once the organization decided to fire Carlisle and hire Larry Brown last summer, there was no outcry over why the coach that produced 100 victories in two seasons had been dismissed.
"I enjoy playing for Coach Brown," Hamilton said. "I think he has made the game fun for me at both ends of the floor. I'm satisfied with the situation here. I didn't have a problem with Rick. If there was something I needed to know I would go up and communicate with him and that was it. Last year was my first year with him and I was only with him for seven or eight months. He's a different guy. He's definitely different."
Ben Wallace, the Pistons' leader on the floor, had problems with Carlisle as far back as the first-round playoff series with Toronto in Carlisle's first year. Antonio Davis, a former Pacer, had a couple of good games to help tie the series at 2, and some comments were made that irritated Wallace. He won't elaborate, but he doesn't need to.
The two-time defensive player of the year finished second this season to Ron Artest in the coaches and media voting. Carlisle campaigned for Artest. When he was the Pistons' coach he made phone calls on Wallace's behalf.
Don't think losing his title as the best defender to Artest has been lost on Wallace, or the campaigning that helped pry it away from him.
Wallace was asked whom would he have picked if he had a vote for the award.
"You mean, if I couldn't vote for myself?" he said. "If I could vote for myself, I'd vote for myself. He'd probably be the next guy in line. The things he does at the defensive end really helps that team and gets that team going.
"Any time a great defender is looking at another defender, you're going to see some things similar to yourself. There aren't many guys who are going to take it upon themselves to go out and be a defender first and worry about the offense later."
But Billups said: "That's definitely motivation for him. Artest is a good defender, but I don't think he has the effect on the game defensively that Ben Wallace does. No way. No how. I know he'll be extra motivated for that. I want him to be aggressive. When he has the opportunity to take it (offensively), I want him to take it. I know defensively he's going to be out there to make a point."
Wallace, of course, is still a great defender, but his role has changed. Instead of standing in the corner and not getting in the way offensively under Carlisle, Wallace has been asked to take an active role.
"I watched tape of Indiana playing him, and they never guarded him," Brown said. "Toronto didn't guard him either, and that's Kevin O'Neill, who coached with Rick. I just think we need everybody to be aggressive offensively."
Joe Dumars, the Pistons' president of basketball operations, recalled how "we'd be out there 4-on-5 or 3-on-5 and it's tough to play like that," when he reflected on the offense under Carlisle.
"He has to take the shot and give us a chance," Dumars said. "Ron and Ben is another subplot. All the subplots are great, but I think they'll be secondary."
Because Carlisle coached most of this season's Pistons last season, Wallace was asked if that would help the Pacers.
"Rick hasn't coached this team," he said. "This is a different team. We've made a lot of changes. We've added a couple of guys and some guys' roles have changed, so we're different than when he was here."
No longer is Ben asked to stand in a corner and score off offensive rebounds or lob dunks. In Game 7 against New Jersey, he scored the Pistons' first two baskets and finished with 18 points on 8-for-10 shooting.
"Coming into this season, my mind was already made up that I was going to go out and take more chances and take more shots because the coaching staff encouraged me to go out there and take more chances and take more shots," Wallace said. "Coach has been in support of it."
And so have his teammates.
"He's the first one here and the last to leave," Billups said. "He shoots more than anybody. He can make those shots. It's just a matter of him becoming more comfortable. . . . He's not used to doing it in game situations, but you can see he's becoming more and more comfortable."
Comment