So you knew for sure you were going to be stuck with him for five years, no questions asked. You were just stuck with him, period. No hope of a trade, a cut, nothing.
Who would you rather it be?
My thoughts: Jamaal. Both are equally questionable attitude-wise, but Jamaal has more raw talent. Neither is a good idea, but if I was stuck with one, I'd rather be stuck with the one with the most potential to help the team win.