Hicks, I JUST bought RDR yesterday and freaking LOVE it. I have a bad habit of getting a game and getting so locked in I play nothing else (Hello MW2), so I bought RDR on blind faith. VERY fun. Of course, I did the sociopathic thing and wasted half and hours killing evveeerryybboody: Dogs, horses, shopkeepers as I laughed maniacally how weird and uncomfortable it was playing in that style.
I'm gonna take my time and savor this game, seeing as how I'm pretty late to the party.