PDA

View Full Version : Salaries Aside, Equal Value



3Ball
11-13-2004, 02:23 PM
All this talk about getting equal value in an Artest trade got me thinking, salary issues aside, just where do y'all value our players. That is to say, who would you say would be an equal trade if they made the same money. A few examples...

Artest = Ben Wallace
Both are fantastic defenders. Artest is a much better offensive player but Ben is a better rebounder and less of a distraction.

O'Neal = Chris Webber
Webber is a better passer with rather better numbers, but older and more injury-prone. He's not yet in the Duncan/Garnet catagory, but maybe in a year or two...

Tinsley = Tony Parker
Tony is a better scorer, but Tinsley is a better floor general (most of Parker's assists amount to -- give it to Duncan in the paint and then jog back to the bench to enjoy some Gatorade while Duncan does his thing). Both are young guns that were drafted too low and have been solid more or less since day 1.

Jackson -- Harrington. Hardy har har.

Miller=Dikembe Mutombo
Both were giants of their day, but their days have long since peaked. Still valuable for their knowledge and their rep (Reg still draws top defenders at the ends of games, and slashers are still a little shy going to the rim with Dikembe guarding it).

What do you think?

sweabs
11-13-2004, 03:30 PM
Artest = T-Mac
J.O. = Shaq
Jackson = Vince Carter
Tinsley = Tony Parker
Miller = Eddie Jones

Diamond Dave
11-13-2004, 04:26 PM
J.O.=Duncan
Cro=Mark Blount
Sjax=someone a little better than Al but not quite as good as Rip Hamilton
Tinsley=Parker
Artest=:bananadead:
Bender does not =:signit:
Pollard=Bra...yeah I'm not gonna say it.

stipo
11-13-2004, 06:56 PM
Love J.O. but he is not, and I dare say it, never will be in the same class as Garnett or T-Dunc.

J.O. -- Great Athlete for a man his size. Decent range. Good but not imaginative passer. Very good rebounder.
Garnett -- UNBELIEVABLE athlete for any size. Plus much better range than J.O.
Duncan -- Only one of the smartest players in the world. To busy quietly killing you to preen. Doesn't care if you notice him. Just quiet satisfaction as he kicks your behind.:cool:

This is why, although I love Jermaine, I think Artest is our best player. There are times when Jermaine is matched up with somebody and I hope he steps up to play with as much greatness. Artest, well, I never worry about him matching up with anyone. (although Tay Prince was in the groove during the playoffs. I think that was an anomoly. sp?) It's the OTHER team that has to adjust.

Just my opinion. Those who disagree are free to be wrong.;)

Shade
11-13-2004, 08:51 PM
JO = Elton Brand
Artest = Kirilenko
Tins = Tony Parker
Reggie = Eddie Jones
Freddie = Jason Richardson
Foster = Rasho Nesterovic