PDA

View Full Version : Harrison PO'd at Star



Sollozzo
08-21-2008, 12:12 AM
http://www.indystar.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080820/SPORTS03/808200378/1058/SPORTS03


Look who's talking: Harrison
Colts' quiet star speaks but offers little insight
By Mike Chappell
Posted: August 20, 2008


Marvin Harrison, the Indianapolis Colts' reticent receiver, broke his silence Tuesday afternoon, but offered little personal insight into his return from knee problems or any other Marvin-related matters.

Speaking to the local media for the first time since the Colts' Jan. 13 divisional playoff loss to San Diego -- and speaking only to The Star -- Harrison made it clear from the outset there wasn't much he cared to share.
Advertisement

A Colts official ended the interview when Harrison was asked about an April 29 shooting in his hometown of Philadelphia that involved a gun he owned.

Before that, Harrison was asked about football. He said he had no comment when asked whether the recent camp in Terre Haute was normal for him. He offered no opinion on whether he is back to where he was before an injury to his left knee forced him to miss 11 games last season.

"I mean, have you been in Terre Haute watching practice?" Harrison said. "You can write what you see. That's the best way I can tell you."

Informed that Colts fans might prefer to hear Harrison's assessment, he said, "You all seem to know more about it . . . you all write what you see. That way I won't have a comment."

Harrison indicated he has been upset with some of what has been written about him. It was mentioned he has had some engaging discussions with the media during previous training camps.

"Oh, yes, we have," Harrison said. "Then sometimes you walk out with that knife in your back sometimes.

"I'll just say nothing. There will be better days down the line, but I have nothing right now."
Call Star reporter Mike Chappell at (317) 444-6830.

__________________________________________________ ____________________


WTF is up with this? Marvin sure can be a strange guy sometimes. Lighten up Marvin, you get paid a bajillion dollars a year to play football. If you would actually answer a question straight up for once instead of beating around the bush about it and giving strange one word answers, then I think there would be a lot less whispering about your condition. God forbid reporters or fans try to find out what is wrong with the teams HOF receiver.

I thought players had to make themselves available to the media at least sometimes?

I used to think Harrison was just a quiet guy, but the more I read about him the more I think that he is a prima donna in the opposite way of a TO or Ocho Cinco.

I just don't get why Harrison has to be so consistently standoffish.

Coop
08-21-2008, 01:15 AM
Wow. Sounds like you're really overreacting. Why are you so upset about this?

You act like you wouldn't get tired of having the exact same questions asked for 6+ months straight. Give the guy a break. If he's healthy and ready to go, he'll be on the field. That's all there is to it.

Trader Joe
08-21-2008, 01:41 AM
Sometimes I feel like this Colts team for all their success still feels extremely unapproachable. I don't know why. The parade immediately after the Super Bowl being the exception.
Harrison is sort of a prima donna Peyton has admitted as much when he says Marvin will always let him know when he doesn't think he is getting the ball enough. He's just so quiet about it, it's not in your face like Chad Johnson or TO. Which is nice for our chemistry.

I don't know, when I look back on these Colts, I think I might remember Harrison as possibly the most talented of the whole bunch, but he definitely won't be the first face that pops into my head. We really don't know him that well, and I think his HOF induction ceremony is just gonna be kind of awkward for everyone involved. I'm not sure what kind of speech he is gonna give.

Trader Joe
08-21-2008, 01:43 AM
Wow. Sounds like you're really overreacting. Why are you so upset about this?

You act like you wouldn't get tired of having the exact same questions asked for 6+ months straight. Give the guy a break. If he's healthy and ready to go, he'll be on the field. That's all there is to it.

It's an occupational hazard. Ask JO about it. When you get injured, especially a major injury like Marvin had, you need to expect to get questioned about it until you show you are back up to speed. It's just the way it is. If Marvin doesn't like it then he should just be 100% quiet, and really just let his play do the talking. Saying something like this is just gonna tick the media off even more, and possibly fuel the fire that Marvin isn't quite ready to go.

Sollozzo
08-21-2008, 01:48 AM
Wow. Sounds like you're really overreacting. Why are you so upset about this?

You act like you wouldn't get tired of having the exact same questions asked for 6+ months straight. Give the guy a break. If he's healthy and ready to go, he'll be on the field. That's all there is to it.

But that's my point. Harrison brings a lot of this on himself by always avoiding questions/reporters. If Harrison would just say something like "The knee is doing better and I'm doing everything I can to get back on the field and produce at a high level" then I think people would back off. But when he gives condescending answers and dodges questions he is opening up more cans of worms.

And you implying that he is mad because people have asked the same questions for 6 straight months would carry more weight if Harrison had ever actually talked to the media in the years before the injury. But he didn't. I mean, you can probably count on one hand (missing fingers) the times that Harrison has actually given straight forward answers to the media. Some may call it quiet, I call it standoffish.

The fans are the reason these players make millions. If we aren't going to games or buying team merchandise, then there is no money available to pay someone like Harrison their millions. The media is the only way for us to get information about the team. Therefore, I don't think it's that unreasonable to expect some non-condescending answers from those involved with the team. Really, would it kill Harrison to just say something like "I'm trying hard to get back to my previous level, the knee held up OK during training camp."

Bball
08-21-2008, 02:55 AM
But that's my point. Harrison brings a lot of this on himself by always avoiding questions/reporters. If Harrison would just say something like "The knee is doing better and I'm doing everything I can to get back on the field and produce at a high level" then I think people would back off. But when he gives condescending answers and dodges questions he is opening up more cans of worms.

And you implying that he is mad because people have asked the same questions for 6 straight months would carry more weight if Harrison had ever actually talked to the media in the years before the injury. But he didn't. I mean, you can probably count on one hand (missing fingers) the times that Harrison has actually given straight forward answers to the media. Some may call it quiet, I call it standoffish.

The fans are the reason these players make millions. If we aren't going to games or buying team merchandise, then there is no money available to pay someone like Harrison their millions. The media is the only way for us to get information about the team. Therefore, I don't think it's that unreasonable to expect some non-condescending answers from those involved with the team. Really, would it kill Harrison to just say something like "I'm trying hard to get back to my previous level, the knee held up OK during training camp."


I have a slightly different take... Why did he bother with this 'breaking of silence' anyway? If you're going to talk, then talk (openly). Otherwise, keep up the silent treatment or just say "no comment".

Even if he's pi$$ed, address it head-on instead of odd, weird comments that really only reflect bad on him (if he can't elaborate or put them in context).

I've noticed Marvin getting more odd over the years. I'm not sure what to make of it.

Kraft
08-21-2008, 03:52 AM
Marvin's really putting a tarnish on his legacy as a Colt. Some he brought on himself, some he didn't. I imagine the part he didn't has left a bad taste in his mouth.

I don't know what professional athletes expect when it comes to media treatment. The good outlets do their jobs, no matter how it makes the players look. Trust me, they don't give a flying flock about what Marvin thinks about them. If he wants to clam up, that'll be reported and he'll look like a jerkoff, which is what happened here.

Fans used to think of him as the quirky, quiet type. Well, the cat's out of the bag now, eh? It's really unfortunate. I prefer the strong, silent type.

Coop
08-21-2008, 03:59 AM
LOL at Marvin getting aggrivated with reporters for the 1st time in 12 seasons, and now his legacy is tarnished.

I just don't feel like he should have an obligation to make sure fans know every single thing about his recovery from an injury. It's his business, and if he doesn't feel like informing everyone, then that's fine. It doesn't make him arrogant, and it sure as hell doesn't take away from his legacy as one of the best WR's of all time.

For the past 12 years, it's obvious that he isn't a person that likes to be the center of attention. I don't see how anything here makes him a prima donna.

RWB
08-21-2008, 07:21 AM
What's funny is Chappy was there EVERYDAY doing his job. It's not like some one day stint from King, Clayton, or the NFL network wasting one day in THaute. Marvin must have really irked Chappell and I'll side with the reporter on this one.

avoidingtheclowns
08-21-2008, 10:12 AM
We really don't know him that well, and I think his HOF induction ceremony is just gonna be kind of awkward for everyone involved. I'm not sure what kind of speech he is gonna give.


"Things change. This is how I live my life. Let's please move on. Thank you."

Sollozzo
08-21-2008, 10:40 AM
LOL at Marvin getting aggrivated with reporters for the 1st time in 12 seasons, and now his legacy is tarnished.

I just don't feel like he should have an obligation to make sure fans know every single thing about his recovery from an injury. It's his business, and if he doesn't feel like informing everyone, then that's fine. It doesn't make him arrogant, and it sure as hell doesn't take away from his legacy as one of the best WR's of all time.

For the past 12 years, it's obvious that he isn't a person that likes to be the center of attention. I don't see how anything here makes him a prima donna.

No one said we have to know "everything" about the injury. All I'm asking is that Marvin give a non-condescending answer when asked about it. That would be better for the fans and better for Marvin, because then I think the media would back off a little. Just say something like "The knee is doing better, and I'm doing everything I can to be 100% this year." That certainly isn't telling us "everything", but it's at least acknowledging the question and giving a legitimate answer.

But when you say "you write what you can see, that's the best way I can tell you", well..that's just being an unnecessary a-hole in my opinion. That's not being a quiet, reserved guy.....that's being a pompous, standoffish one. Chappel seems to be a good guy and was just doing his job.

You don't have to be loud like TO or Ocho Cinco to be a prima donna. I think Marv is a prima donna in the opposite way of those guys.

Suaveness
08-21-2008, 10:48 AM
For the love of god, who cares? Marvin has always disliked talking to people. I will always think of him as a great football player, and that's all I need to know. Tarnished? Please.

Sollozzo
08-21-2008, 11:05 AM
For the love of god, who cares? Marvin has always disliked talking to people. I will always think of him as a great football player, and that's all I need to know. Tarnished? Please.


Judging by the comments here, the comments on other Colts forums, and the comments posted under the actual article; plenty of people care. I see a trend of more and more fans growing tired of Harrison's standoffish behavior

I love him as a football player. I hope he gets 1200 yds and 12 touchdowns for the Colts this year. But that doesn't change the fact that he is aloof and standoffish.

SoupIsGood
08-21-2008, 11:54 AM
I really just don't care. And we occasionally hear stories about how Peyton is high-maintenance and sometimes sort of a jerk too, you know, if we're going to be nitpicking the personalities of future HOF'ers.

I've never really thought of these Colts of the past few years as unapproachable. Marvin's a little quiet, sure, but Tony D., Peyton, Dwight, Bob, Reggie, Joe, etc.? All of them strike me as pretty gregarious and friendly. (Granted I've never met any of them.)

Since86
08-21-2008, 01:12 PM
I think this is completely blown out of proportion.

For me, this is all I need to know:

Harrison indicated he has been upset with some of what has been written about him. It was mentioned he has had some engaging discussions with the media during previous training camps.

"Oh, yes, we have," Harrison said. "Then sometimes you walk out with that knife in your back sometimes.

To me, it indicates that he has openned up in the past to the media and he felt like they went opposite of it and "stabbed him in the back."

If you have an already bad relationship with someone, or an organization, but have to be available to them due to your job description, are you really going to go out of your way to be friendly, open, and 100% honest? I know I wouldn't. If I felt slighted by them, I would keep everything close to my chest.

He's exactly right. They need to write what they see. Is he making cuts like the Marv before injury, or is he favoring the knee?

I think this illustrates his point about getting upset with them:

A Colts official ended the interview when Harrison was asked about an April 29 shooting in his hometown of Philadelphia that involved a gun he owned.

Yes, I know it's news. But it's been how long and nothing for him has came out of it? Let it go already, unless something new comes out.


He's already extremely quiet and obviously gonna go deeper into his shell if you poke and prod him.

Sollozzo
08-21-2008, 01:27 PM
I have a slightly different take... Why did he bother with this 'breaking of silence' anyway? If you're going to talk, then talk (openly). Otherwise, keep up the silent treatment or just say "no comment".

Even if he's pi$$ed, address it head-on instead of odd, weird comments that really only reflect bad on him (if he can't elaborate or put them in context).

I've noticed Marvin getting more odd over the years. I'm not sure what to make of it.

I have to wonder if Marvin isn't mad at the Colts for how they handled his condition last year. It's obvious he had absolutely no business playing and should have been on the IR. I wonder if he thinks the Colts rushed him back to quickly for the Jacksonville game? I remember reading that it was Marv who said that he couldn't play in the final game of the season. Or he could think the Colts put him in a bad situation against SD when he still had no business playing. His mind was on his knee, and not protecting the football (not his fault).

I would just like to know what it was that ticked him off. I don't remember The Star ever hanging him after the Philly incident. Am I wrong about that? I mean, they initially reported it as did every news outlet, but they seemed to let it go after nothing came out of it. Chappel wouldn't be doing his job if he didn't ask Harrison about it.

Is Harrison seriously mad because people were whispering about his condition last year? If the Colts and Harrison weren't so super secretive about the injury, then there would be nothing to whisper about.

Noodle
08-21-2008, 01:33 PM
Wow, a few PD'ers got their feelings hurt again. Why? In this world, there are different types of personalities. Marvin is a introvert. For the record, so am I. People like us are quiet socially, but always have an edge that drives us to succeed. At times we snap, it's a much needed release, as keeping quiet and leading by example is what gets us to the top. The more the media tries, the more Marvin will get annoyed, just a personality trait. He has been good, no outstanding, for 12 years, he was bound to snap. At least it was subtle lashing. **** all these media type liberal candy***es anyway. Dissect this if you guys want, but no one outside of Indy is listening or cares.

Tarnished? On Sunday's you won't be thinking that when he makes a one handed grab in the corner of the end zone while dragging two feet for six.

With all the legitimate off field problems involving Indy professional sports, I'd like to think we all know what's really bad and not so bad. This not so bad. Mr. Talks-A-Lot needs to relax when quiet guys gets annoyed, because quiet guy is tired of listening to Mr. Talks-A-Lot.

Sollozzo
08-21-2008, 02:49 PM
He's exactly right. They need to write what they see. Is he making cuts like the Marv before injury, or is he favoring the knee?



But if all they should do is "write what they see", then there would never be a need to interview any player/coach/what have you. That would be pretty boring wouldn't it? Players/coaches are interviewed to get a unique, inside perspective that only they can give. Interviews are the entire basis of sports coverage. That's how we really learn what's going on. Without interviews, all Chappel would be giving was an opinion. So I think that Marvin Harrison's thoughts on the knee are far more valuable than what Chapel or any one else can observe with their eyes.

Sure it *looks* like he is doing okay and not favoring the knee. All we can do is give an educated guess. However, Marvin's opinion on it would be infinitely more valuable than anything Chapel or anyone has to say about it.

That's my problem with it. I don't expect Harrison to give some in depth answer about his knee, but would it have killed him to just say something like "it's doing okay, i'm trying everything I can to get back to 100% this year." I don't think it would. Is it really necessary to give such condescending answers?

Maybe I'm overreacting, and I can see your points with the rest of your posts. I understand that Harrison is going to always be a quiet guy, and I have ZERO problem with that. However, I don't think it's necessary for him to be so consistently standoffish with people. I mean, lighten up a bit Marvin. You've spent 12 great years here and the people here want so badly to have a relationship with you. I don't think that is too unnecessary given the fact that most fans support the team financially in some way.

Since86
08-21-2008, 03:07 PM
That's my problem with it. I don't expect Harrison to give some in depth answer about his knee, but would it have killed him to just say something like "it's doing okay, i'm trying everything I can to get back to 100% this year." I don't think it would. Is it really necessary to give such condescending answers?

After years hearing JO talk about how he's fine and all that, you really expect to get a straight answer? I would much rather evaluate someone's performance, and how they move than have them tell me.

Players play, and they're never going to give you the 100% truth.

Let me ask you this. If a reporter asked Peyton how his knee was feeling, what would you expect him to say? My guess is, he's going to give an answer that makes it seem like it's doing better than it really is because of his desire to get back. I see no difference in Marv, especially considering all the talk last season.

If I remember correctly, weren't you up in arms about not getting straight answers during that time? I doubt much has changed, answering question-wise not the injury.

Arcadian
08-21-2008, 03:33 PM
Sometimes I think it is OK simply to be one of the best to ever play at your position and not a celebrity/PR man/ambassador. Just because a man can catch a football doesn't make him an ambassador. Conversely not being a ambassador doesn't make him a jerk. It is just who he is. If he couldn't play the way he did no one on here would care if he was a good person or not.

duke dynamite
08-21-2008, 06:27 PM
We see what we see.

Is he playing? Yes. Marvin is back.

He is just calling everyone Mr. Obvious.

D-BONE
08-21-2008, 08:56 PM
Well, those comments could "mean" any number of things, one very real possibility being nothing really. If he comes back and is able to produce nobody will care about this little dustup.

On the other hand, maybe he's irritated b/c Reggie Wayne has surpassed him in terms what have you done for me lately and exterior profile. Is Marvin, perhaps due to age, now 1A or 2 even if physically sound?

Kegboy
08-22-2008, 04:03 PM
On the other hand, maybe he's irritated b/c Reggie Wayne has surpassed him in terms what have you done for me lately and exterior profile.

Seriously, has Marvin ever given you any indication he cares about his "exterior profile"?

IMO, the Star sucks, glad to see someone give them **** once in a while.

Sollozzo
08-22-2008, 04:20 PM
After years hearing JO talk about how he's fine and all that, you really expect to get a straight answer? I would much rather evaluate someone's performance, and how they move than have them tell me.

Players play, and they're never going to give you the 100% truth.

Let me ask you this. If a reporter asked Peyton how his knee was feeling, what would you expect him to say? My guess is, he's going to give an answer that makes it seem like it's doing better than it really is because of his desire to get back. I see no difference in Marv, especially considering all the talk last season.

If I remember correctly, weren't you up in arms about not getting straight answers during that time? I doubt much has changed, answering question-wise not the injury.

Fair point. It's doubtful that Harrison would be very straight forward, I guess I'm just a little turned off by his tone. It would be nice to know how he really feels about his knee, if the naysayers are what's motivating him this year, and what the heck happened in Philly. You make a good point that there's no way we'd ever get those answers from Harrison, but it certainly would be nice to know what he thinks.

This is what I want to know: What in the world did the Star do to tick him off? I see people here saying that the Star got what it deserved and stuff, but what exactly do to deserve it? I read Chappell and Richards weekly, and I think they do a pretty fair job of covering this team. I certainly think they're better than the guys who cover the Pacers.

If an 8 time pro bowl receiver is out for game after game with no straight answer, then I think that needs to be addressed. And I'm sorry, but Chappell and Richards wouldn't have been doing their jobs if they didn't question what happened in Philadelphia on that night.

MarionDeputy
08-23-2008, 10:34 AM
Harrison is most definitely a Hall of Fame player, but his career has been marred, in my opinion, by several factors:

1. His stand-off'ish dealing with the media - like them or not a proffessional athelete must learn how to communicate with them.

2. His shoving of an IPD officer in the Circle Center parking garage

3. His battery settlement to the fan in Hawaii while there for the pro-bowl

4. And his most recent dust-up with his gun being used to shoot one person and wounding of an innocent child.

Coop
08-24-2008, 05:36 AM
Harrison is most definitely a Hall of Fame player, but his career has been marred, in my opinion, by several factors:

1. His stand-off'ish dealing with the media - like them or not a proffessional athelete must learn how to communicate with them.

2. His shoving of an IPD officer in the Circle Center parking garage

3. His battery settlement to the fan in Hawaii while there for the pro-bowl

4. And his most recent dust-up with his gun being used to shoot one person and wounding of an innocent child.


1. No, they don't. It's the athletes choice of whether or not they talk with the media. If they don't want to, that in no way shape or form detracts from what they do on the field.

2. Haven't heard about that. Have a link?

3. Haven't heard about this either so I can't comment.

4. Unless he is proven guilty of something, you can't say his career is marred because someone else used one of his weapons to commit a crime. How did the shooter get the weapon? Was it stolen?

I just think a lot of people are way too quick to say Marvin is tarnishing this, or ruining that. Give the guy a freaking break. He has been an upstanding citizen, and excellent role-model for 12 years. Why must everyone grasp for straws trying to take away from that?

naptownmenace
08-25-2008, 01:21 PM
Meh... :shrug:

Much ado about nothing, IMO.

Roaming Gnome
08-25-2008, 04:37 PM
Meh... :shrug:

Much ado about nothing, IMO.

I'd have to agree... Marvin, get back to doing what you do on the field. I personally could give the "business end of a rat" on how he deals with the media, especially the poor excuse of journallist we have in this market.

IMO, the guy isn't paid to accomodate media request, he is paid to catch footballs. So what if he doesn't want to talk to the media that he feels has already done him wrong in the past. Whether it is true or not, that is his perception. Making it his reality.

MarionDeputy
08-26-2008, 08:37 PM
1. No, they don't. It's the athletes choice of whether or not they talk with the media. If they don't want to, that in no way shape or form detracts from what they do on the field.

Just sharing my opinion, I personally believe that proffessional athletes are paid to do more than just perform on the field.


2. Haven't heard about that. Have a link?

It's in the archive section of the Indy Star see the 4th article down I didn't want to buy, as I have read the police report and know one of the responding officers.

http://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?s_site=indystar&f_site=indystar&f_sitename=Indianapolis+Star%2FNews%2C+The+%28IN%2 9&p_theme=gannett&p_product=IN&p_action=search&p_field_base-0=&p_text_base-0=Marvin+Harrison+police+officer&Search=Search&p_perpage=10&p_maxdocs=200&p_queryname=700&s_search_type=keyword&p_sort=_rank_%3AD&p_field_date-0=YMD_date&p_params_date-0=date%3AB%2CE&p_text_date-0=

This was during the time that Chief of Police over saw security for the police, there was a tape of Harrison chest bumping the officer that dissapeared from the evidence locker. Wasn't a huge deal in the publics eye, but in my circle it was.

3. Haven't heard about this either so I can't comment.

Here is the link for pro bowl incident http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=2025485


4. Unless he is proven guilty of something, you can't say his career is marred because someone else used one of his weapons to commit a crime. How did the shooter get the weapon? Was it stolen?

I believe responsible gun owners should be in control of their weapons at all times. The shooting stemmed from a fist fight that Marvin was in with another guy in Marvin's bar, shortly afterwards that guy is shot with Marvin's gun. The gun is found in a bucket in Marvin's car wash. And originally Marvin denied that his gun was even involved.

http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/news/story?id=3382026


I just think a lot of people are way too quick to say Marvin is tarnishing this, or ruining that. Give the guy a freaking break. He has been an upstanding citizen, and excellent role-model for 12 years. Why must everyone grasp for straws trying to take away from that?

As I said originally this is just my opinion, you are certainly entitled to yours. I just think pro athletes like Manning, Reggie and Jermaine Oneal recognize and demonstrate good citizenship and demonstrate class on a consistent basis. I would say that Marvin has not been an upstanding citizen nor an excellent role model for any kid. He is however an incredible athlete and one of the top wide recivers to have ever played the game.

MarionDeputy
08-26-2008, 08:40 PM
especially the poor excuse of journallist we have in this market.

Couldn't agree with you more....what passes for journalism in this city is an embarssment to journalism everywhere.

Sollozzo
08-26-2008, 08:58 PM
I personally could give the "business end of a rat" on how he deals with the media, especially the poor excuse of journallist we have in this market.


I don't get it. Why is the overall tone here supporting Harrison instead of the media? Maybe sometimes the media in Indy sucks, but I think that Chappell and Richards (I read them several times a week) are pretty decent guys who try to cover the team as well as they can. I certainly pick up a lot of valuable info from them. Keep in mind that the Colts aren't exactly the most divulging organization out there. It can be pretty hard to get certain info out of them, so sometimes the reporters info is limited. They aren't "poor excuses of journalists", but are 2 guys who wouldn't be doing their jobs if they didn't ask questions.

I've heard people complain on here that the Star is the Pacers lap dog. But now people are supporting Harrison because the Star might have asked a few prying questions that hurt his feelings? What gives? Do you want a media that is a lapdog, or one that tries to ask relevant questions (like chap and richards)? I've heard plenty of complaining on here about both, and can't figure it out.

I'm going to assume that it's either one, or a combination, of 2 things that ticked him off.

1) He didn't like the whispers about where he was when he missed all that time last year.

2) He didn't like them reporting about the incident in Philly.

These were two pretty relevant issues. If the media didn't speculate about where he was last year then they would be p*ss poor at their jobs. And the same can be said about the gun issue last year. Sorry Marv, if your weapon is used in a felony then that is newsworthy information. That's a price you pay for being a professional athlete. Harrison has no trouble pocketing the millions of dollars that he makes by being a great receiver, but seems to want no part of having any of his private life in the spotlight. Unfortunately, that's a price you pay when you are famous. Sometimes you can't have your cake and eat it too.

Now if there is something that we don't know about that made Harrison upset at the reporters, then I am willing to change my mind on it. But I think its likely that it's one of these 2 things that made him mad. And I'm siding with Chap here...he's just doing his job.

Noodle
08-27-2008, 02:29 AM
I remember that story of the pro bowl incident. Smells like someone wanted to scheme some Benjamin's there.

Plus, police officers use excessive force all the time and get out of line sometimes just to show their butt to high profile people. I don't know enough to say that Marvin was wrong in this. I'm not high profile, but I've been involved in similar incidents. I was accused of battery for breaking the officers right index finger, and the breaking of the finger was intentional, but he assaulted me on camera with no probable reasoning, he just didn't like my attitude or my knowledge of the law. The charge was immediately dropped. The tape somehow disappeared.

I was attacked in a airport luggage area in South Carolina intervening with a assault on a woman. I was a minor at the time, little did he know, and was assaulted by a forty year old man. I never laid a finger on him until he jumped me, I just told him to leave her alone. It turns out that he was the younger brother of the man in charge of airport security. I you see were this is going the tape magically disappeared.

Maybe, Marvin could be a bad guy. I just don't care until there is a real, complete story. If you want to dig up trash on any single high profile person in the world, go to cracked.com and indulge yourself. At that site you can pull up tons of rumors and BS stories that never became much of anything because they were ruled out as a scheme or a rumor. There are real stories that were covered in depth by the media on that site as well, mostly BS though. On that site our golden boy Peyton apparently was accused of sexual misconduct. I agree get off the soap box and give the guy a freakin' break.

Kraft
08-27-2008, 12:31 PM
I guess I'm a little surprised at how many people are willing to turn a blind eye to a lot of things from Harrison. Anyone know why? Is it his production? Or maybe there have been too many game-day reports on how Marvin hides from the spotlight and eats Tasty Cakes?

For a guy who doesn't want to be bothered or make waves, Marvin sure has a funny way of showing it.

Since86
08-27-2008, 12:37 PM
Blind eye?

What is there to turn a blind eye too? So what he's a P*ick to the media? Should he be fined for giving incomplete answers? Should he never set foot in the HOF? Should he be suspended?

Why in the world you really care how an athlete answers questions to the media is beyond me. I believe Peter King to be one of the best, if not the best writers, in football and he'll even tell you that while he has good relationships with a lot of players that he is not their "friend," which has caused him to burn a few bridges with some players.

Marvin doesn't even open up to his teammates, and you honestly expect him to open up to a beat writer?

We don't need to know everything, he does have the right to privacy. How do you not make waves? "No comment" might be the best answer, but I'm still sure there would be some complaining about that.

Kraft
08-27-2008, 12:50 PM
What is there to turn a blind eye too?

I'm talking about points Nos. 2, 3 and 4 in MarionDeputy's post.

I could care less if he's a big talker with the media or not. But if he wanted to be left alone, the best strategy would be to give reporters a canned answer. "Yes, the knee is doing better. Thank you." If you came off the way Marvin did recently, that's going to draw attention. I'm sure he knew that. That's why he did it.

Bball
08-27-2008, 03:08 PM
Class and/or respect- Marvin showed neither in his answer to the Star. That's the problem. It's not that he didn't want to talk or that he refused, it is that he answered as a total prick. Considering he's coming off a season lost to injury that was handled rather strangely (at least as far as the public is concerned) and has an 'issue' with a handgun and shooting that has been more swept under the rug than explained and excused, I don't think it's asking too much for Harrison to 'man up' and face the media... Nor do I think the media is out of line asking about those things. That is their job. They would be out of line if they didn't ask those questions.

If Marvin doesn't want to answer... then don't. Just STFU, give a canned ambiguous (but respectful answer), or say "no comment". Better yet, especially in regards to the Philly incident hand out/fax a prepared statement and end it with a tag that this is all that will said by Marvin on the subject. Then pull out the "no comments" if reporters ask further about it. Eventually they'll get the idea if they need more information on it, they'll have to ask someone besides Marvin. (Of course by asking Marvin directly they are offering him the chance to get out in front of it and relate his side and/or exactly how he wants the incident to be framed).

Marvin has no high ground to stand on in this debate and Adam is exactly right. The Star reporter(s) have done nothing wrong and asking tough questions is their job. It's not even like these were tough questions.

I stand by my statements that Marvin seems to be getting stranger as time goes on. That's certainly his right but that doesn't allow him to not use common sense and face reality.

He doesn't owe the public and press anything... EXCEPT... a little respect. If he wants it himself, he needs far less 'interviews' like this one.

gilpdawg
08-27-2008, 05:36 PM
Marvin's a dick.

But I don't care. His job is to play football, not be a nice guy.

ChicagoJ
08-28-2008, 12:02 AM
Whatever happened to, "Both teams played hard" as the universal answer to every stupid reporter's questions?

Merz
08-31-2008, 11:07 PM
I'm talking about points Nos. 2, 3 and 4 in MarionDeputy's post.



Well point number three is invalid because this same hawaiian family that tried getting Harrison for assault had tried the same scam (just with a different family member) before to no avail.

Before you ask, no I don't have a link as I don't really feel like searching for it. You can either take my word for it or search for a link yourself.


As for the topic...its pretty rediculous. So he is standoffish and coming off like a jerk in the newspaper, big deal. You know he's human. His career will not be tarnished because of this. The media as a whole has been pretty bad to him over the past year. Yeah, he shouldn't pigeonhole them all together but you certainly can't blame him.

Gamble1
08-31-2008, 11:33 PM
The fatt dudes sidekick on 950AM is the most over done person in INDYS media. He rambles on about Marvin and Peytons conditions like he was a right to know.

The media here is a joke.
I really have a hard time listening/reading about the colts.

Gamble1
08-31-2008, 11:38 PM
Marvin's a dick.

But I don't care. His job is to play football, not be a nice guy.

Sounds like your speaking from experience.

I really don't believe athletes are all that bad its just there jobs are more than just the sport.

If I had to deal with media/fans every week I would probably become bittered at their lack of understanding and constant badgering. Can any of you relate to Marvin anyhow? I can't and I don't really want to.