http://www.startribune.com/150/story/512639.html
Jim Souhan: It's time to trade Garnett
The Wolves need to start over, and dealing their star would be a good move for both player and team.
Jim Souhan, Star Tribune
Last update: June 25, 2006 – 7:22 AM
He's a tall, lanky power forward whose passionate play made him a Minnesota icon, and he became one of the NBA's most dominant players in his prime. So it's sad to say that it's time for Kevin to go, especially because the Kevin in question now bears the surname "Garnett." Last season, Kevin Garnett maintained a statistical profile of all-around excellence even while the Timberwolves imploded. That is a good reason to admire him. That is a better reason to trade him.
A flawed, poorly run team could not contend last season when one of the NBA's supposedly elite players was healthy and productive.
Now virtually the same management team and virtually the same coaching staff will try to win with virtually the same roster, with two exceptions:
1. Garnett will be a year older, at 30, having averaged 39 high-energy minutes per game.
2. Rashad McCants, the developing player with the best chance of improving the Wolves, is out indefinitely after undergoing microfracture knee surgery, a frightening injury for a player who relies on explosiveness.
This leaves the Wolves with two choices:
1. Make a desperate move, trading for a problematic player like Stephon Marbury, to pair Garnett with someone who could make the Wolves contenders.
2. Start over.
Admit that such a desperate move probably would fail, and that if it succeeded it would not get the Wolves much more than a first-round playoff loss.
Admit that Garnett's career has been wasted on a franchise that mismanaged talent, blew draft picks and cheated blatantly on the Joe Smith signing.
Admit that even with Garnett healthy and at his best, the 2006-07 Wolves will not be an attractive draw to fans disgusted by the current regime's mistakes.
Admit that having Garnett healthy will keep the Wolves competitive enough that the odds will be against earning a transformative draft choice.
Admit that Garnett's trade value will only decrease if he continues to log major minutes for bad teams, wearing down his knees and patience.
As painful as it might be to accept, starting over is the way to go.
Keep Garnett, and what you'll have is another lost season to go with a lost opportunity to overhaul a franchise in need of a fresh start.
Garnett is the Wolves' only healthy, valuable asset worth more than a light rail token.
Not only must he be traded, but he must be traded in one of those subtle, fan-angering moves that isn't fully appreciated for years.
Garnett is of best use to the only franchise for which he has played if he becomes the Wolves' Chuck Knoblauch, A.J. Pierzynski or Herschel Walker.
Remember, Twins fans thought their franchise was giving up when Terry Ryan made his deals. The Knoblauch deals built the foundation of three straight division championships. The Pierzynski deal brought Joe Nathan, Francisco Liriano and Boof Bonser. Herschel Walker ... well, you probably remember that one, too.
The Wolves need to trade for young, affordable talent and quality draft picks, and then display the kind of patience that has been void in the organization.
Which leads us to the most legitimate concern about trading Garnett: that the current brain trust might not be capable of making the right deal, or the right kind of deal.
Kevin McHale seems to believe his roster is a few tweaks away from the playoffs. Owner Glen Taylor has refused to fire McHale, an indication that Taylor thinks everything is running smoothly.
Virtually everyone who doesn't draw a paycheck from Taylor knows the franchise is almost beyond repair.
What is wrong with the Wolves, Garnett can't fix alone, and that's his only option if he stays.
So it's time to trade Garnett, not for his sake, but because trading him is the only way a wayward franchise can start over with a workable plan and realistic expectations.
Jim Souhan can be heard Sundays from 10 a.m.-noon on KSTP AM 1500. jsouhan@startribune.com
__________________
Jim Souhan: It's time to trade Garnett
The Wolves need to start over, and dealing their star would be a good move for both player and team.
Jim Souhan, Star Tribune
Last update: June 25, 2006 – 7:22 AM
He's a tall, lanky power forward whose passionate play made him a Minnesota icon, and he became one of the NBA's most dominant players in his prime. So it's sad to say that it's time for Kevin to go, especially because the Kevin in question now bears the surname "Garnett." Last season, Kevin Garnett maintained a statistical profile of all-around excellence even while the Timberwolves imploded. That is a good reason to admire him. That is a better reason to trade him.
A flawed, poorly run team could not contend last season when one of the NBA's supposedly elite players was healthy and productive.
Now virtually the same management team and virtually the same coaching staff will try to win with virtually the same roster, with two exceptions:
1. Garnett will be a year older, at 30, having averaged 39 high-energy minutes per game.
2. Rashad McCants, the developing player with the best chance of improving the Wolves, is out indefinitely after undergoing microfracture knee surgery, a frightening injury for a player who relies on explosiveness.
This leaves the Wolves with two choices:
1. Make a desperate move, trading for a problematic player like Stephon Marbury, to pair Garnett with someone who could make the Wolves contenders.
2. Start over.
Admit that such a desperate move probably would fail, and that if it succeeded it would not get the Wolves much more than a first-round playoff loss.
Admit that Garnett's career has been wasted on a franchise that mismanaged talent, blew draft picks and cheated blatantly on the Joe Smith signing.
Admit that even with Garnett healthy and at his best, the 2006-07 Wolves will not be an attractive draw to fans disgusted by the current regime's mistakes.
Admit that having Garnett healthy will keep the Wolves competitive enough that the odds will be against earning a transformative draft choice.
Admit that Garnett's trade value will only decrease if he continues to log major minutes for bad teams, wearing down his knees and patience.
As painful as it might be to accept, starting over is the way to go.
Keep Garnett, and what you'll have is another lost season to go with a lost opportunity to overhaul a franchise in need of a fresh start.
Garnett is the Wolves' only healthy, valuable asset worth more than a light rail token.
Not only must he be traded, but he must be traded in one of those subtle, fan-angering moves that isn't fully appreciated for years.
Garnett is of best use to the only franchise for which he has played if he becomes the Wolves' Chuck Knoblauch, A.J. Pierzynski or Herschel Walker.
Remember, Twins fans thought their franchise was giving up when Terry Ryan made his deals. The Knoblauch deals built the foundation of three straight division championships. The Pierzynski deal brought Joe Nathan, Francisco Liriano and Boof Bonser. Herschel Walker ... well, you probably remember that one, too.
The Wolves need to trade for young, affordable talent and quality draft picks, and then display the kind of patience that has been void in the organization.
Which leads us to the most legitimate concern about trading Garnett: that the current brain trust might not be capable of making the right deal, or the right kind of deal.
Kevin McHale seems to believe his roster is a few tweaks away from the playoffs. Owner Glen Taylor has refused to fire McHale, an indication that Taylor thinks everything is running smoothly.
Virtually everyone who doesn't draw a paycheck from Taylor knows the franchise is almost beyond repair.
What is wrong with the Wolves, Garnett can't fix alone, and that's his only option if he stays.
So it's time to trade Garnett, not for his sake, but because trading him is the only way a wayward franchise can start over with a workable plan and realistic expectations.
Jim Souhan can be heard Sundays from 10 a.m.-noon on KSTP AM 1500. jsouhan@startribune.com
__________________
Comment